Sundown, what you are doing is judging a product by it's looks and opinions of those who have never tried one.
First, look at the wear pattern of your OEM rear tire. It is likely going bald in a 3-3.5" center track. Ask yourself, 'Why is this?' It's because that's all the rubber you have in contact with the road surface most of the time. The 225/50R 15 has an average tread width of 8.9". But most of it isn't even touching the ground as you ride. This is why the outside 2" or so on both sides of the OEM tire will be virtually new when the center wears out - they never touch the ground and you get little, if any, benefit from the wider tread.
Now the narrower 205/60R 15 Vredestein tire has a width of 8.1". But the superior construction of this tire makes sure the full 8.1" of rubber in the tread width is on the ground at all times. The tread will wear evenly across the entire width for this reason. Plus, the Vredestein sheds water better than any other tire we've found that fits the Spyder.
'Don't judge a book by its cover' can be good advice. It's important to look at the entire equation, not just the first number you see.