Foremost vs. Allstate

[Michiganspyderman]

I'm ready to pull the trigger and move my insurance coverage to Foremost from Progressive. I also have a good quote from Allstate that is a more well known company. Several folks have stated that Foremost is competitive and are happy with their coverage. Has anyone had any real life interaction with Foremost (i.e. filed a claim, utilized their road side assistance program,...)? My gut says Foremost will be fine but I's like some reassurance from someone who has actually dealt with them more than just on paper. Thx!

 

[etaoin]

I recently moved FROM Foremost to Geico. In Kansas, Foremost simply was not price-competitive by a long-shot. I think rates differ from state-to-state. Need to shop around.

 

[thereverend]

Same here

I'm ready to pull the trigger and move my insurance coverage to Foremost from Progressive. I also have a good quote from Allstate that is a more well known company. Several folks have stated that Foremost is competitive and are happy with their coverage. Has anyone had any real life interaction with Foremost (i.e. filed a claim, utilized their road side assistance program,...)? My gut says Foremost will be fine but I's like some reassurance from someone who has actually dealt with them more than just on paper. Thx!

I moved from Foremost to Geico simply for the lower cost..

 

[MikeT]

Insurance rates are based on:
1. Zip Code,
2. Coverage Limits,
3. Age of Policy(new vs. renewal), and
4. Discounts
That's why comparing insurance just on premium paid is so inaccurate.

 

[Illinois Boy]

I'm ready to pull the trigger and move my insurance coverage to Foremost from Progressive. I also have a good quote from Allstate that is a more well known company. Several folks have stated that Foremost is competitive and are happy with their coverage. Has anyone had any real life interaction with Foremost (i.e. filed a claim, utilized their road side assistance program,...)? My gut says Foremost will be fine but I's like some reassurance from someone who has actually dealt with them more than just on paper. Thx!

Pricing is something you'll have to compare. Just make sure you are comparing apples to apples; where all features/benefits are exactly the same. Too many times there are differences in policy coverage which helps lower premiums.

However, I had Foremost once and had an unbelievably great experience with their claims-paying.

I had a HD Ultra-Classic that was nearly totaled. Foremost was great to work with on this claim and helped me in many ways to get the bike back to 100%. They even came to my defense against my local dealer who did not want to replace a few things (if you can believe that). Progressive did this with no hassles at all. I could not say enough about my positive experience with them that entire situation.

I did, however, switch insurance later simply because of a drastic difference in rates. I do wonder though if it would be worth paying more for them for if I were ever to have another claim. Who knows? I certainly hope I never find out.

 

[Michiganspyderman]

Pricing is something you'll have to compare. Just make sure you are comparing apples to apples; where all features/benefits are exactly the same. Too many times there are differences in policy coverage which helps lower premiums.

However, I had Foremost once and had an unbelievably great experience with their claims-paying.

I had a HD Ultra-Classic that was nearly totaled. Foremost was great to work with on this claim and helped me in many ways to get the bike back to 100%. They even came to my defense against my local dealer who did not want to replace a few things (if you can believe that). Progressive did this with no hassles at all. I could not say enough about my positive experience with them that entire situation.

I did, however, switch insurance later simply because of a drastic difference in rates. I do wonder though if it would be worth paying more for them for if I were ever to have another claim. Who knows? I certainly hope I never find out.

Thanks! Based on the minimal # of responses, many use Foremost but luckily have never had to file a claim which is what I'm really looking to find out about - how was their experience?

 

[MarcusB]

Foremost

I have Foremost & have them for years, very price competitive. I had a claim on my Spyder last year & service & cliam handling was great. They are part of Farmers Ins. This was my first (and last i hope) claim. But no problems, & I used to handle auto/ cycle insurance claims before i retired. Hopes this helps, MarcusB

 

[Deer Slayer]

I have had two interactions with Progressive. All were just great. My last in California would have made a great TV spot. I had just KO a deer and Gl 1800 and it could not have gone any smoother. In NC I could save some but I don't think it is worth it. :dg1:

 

[SpyderAnn01]

Foremost has their headquarters in Caledonia, MI which was very close to where I used to live, they were well respected in the community and I have positive things about their products. AARP uses them.

 

[Bob Denman]

As an Independent Insurance Agent, with 37 years of experience...
Pricing, while important; :lecturef_smilie: should NEVER be used as the main consideration when purchasing insurance.
Ultimately; it comes down to policy servicing... How well a company handles a claim, can make all of the difference! :shocked:

 

[BikerDoc]

Insurance rates are based on:
1. Zip Code,
2. Coverage Limits,
3. Age of Policy(new vs. renewal), and
4. Discounts
That's why comparing insurance just on premium paid is so inaccurate.

That is so true... and I really hate it when someone comes on here and says they got "full coverage".. Of course there is no such thing. There are simply hundreds, maybe thousands of different coverage combinations that will result in different prices even from the same company

 

[Michiganspyderman]

Agree...

As an Independent Insurance Agent, with 37 years of experience...
Pricing, while important; :lecturef_smilie: should NEVER be used as the main consideration when purchasing insurance.
Ultimately; it comes down to policy servicing... How well a company handles a claim, can make all of the difference! :shocked:

...that's why I asked the group for personal experiences with the referenced companies. I have 3 "apples to apples" quotes and wanted to know about the performance of each when a claim was submitted.

 

[Vossr]

I have Foremost

I like the company. I wrecked my Yamaha Tour Deluxe last year. They handled everything. I had no problems with them at all.

 

[Bob Denman]

...that's why I asked the group for personal experiences with the referenced companies. I have 3 "apples to apples" quotes and wanted to know about the performance of each when a claim was submitted.

All things being equal: Pick the Company that specializes in it's PowerSports program. :thumbup:
In this case; that would be Foremost...

 

[Michiganspyderman]

All things being equal: Pick the Company that specializes in it's PowerSports program. :thumbup:
In this case; that would be Foremost...

DONE!! Thanks!

 

[ricford]

DONE!! Thanks!

I've used Foremost for the last 5 motorcycles. I use them now for my '14 RT. I also had Foremost on my house and made two large claims. They quickly paid those claims (storm damage). Based on internet searches, Allstate is rated as the number one WORST insurance company in America and Progressive gives millions of dollars each year to the ACLU. But as always, it's your choice.

 

[J48cruiser]

insurance

Foremost is the best had a claim last year they took care of it with no problems and fast and if you are a member of aarp they include great roadside assistance

 

[Bob Denman]

Based on internet searches, Allstate is rated as the number one WORST insurance company in America and Progressive gives millions of dollars each year to the ACLU. But as always, it's your choice.

There's a little bit more to that story...
Allstate's rating is in part due to how they handle third party claims... :shocked:
If you are involved in an accident with an Allstate Customer; they will fight tooth and nail, to pay less than what the actual damages are.
I've have personally seen instances where an Allstate driver has rear-ended one of our clients, and they refused to pay 100% of the damages...
Ours is a "comparative negligence" State; You get reimbursed based upon the percentage of the accident that was the other guy's fault...
Allstate NEVER wants to admit 100% negligence! :gaah:
Now; they treat their own customers differently...

I'm no fan of either Company... :shocked:

 

[Pirate looks at --]

Did you know

That the President of Foremost is the largest suppoter of..................Sorry I couldn't resist after reading the Progressive thread. I have Foremost, I have not had the opportunity to use them yet, thankfully.

 

[Bob Denman]

I'm not a fan of either of the two Companies that have been mentioned...
But it's for reasons that are completely immaterial to this conversation.
As is Politics... Are you protecting your bike, or are you voting? :dontknow: