I really would like to see examples of your quoted “cutting your throat” or “damaging your windpipe” occurrences, Jack. With your head bent forward at its maximum angle, the bottom of the Shoei 3/4 shield actually rests on your breastbone, way below your throat and wind pipe.......and a full face and modular helmet rests in exactly the same position, so they, with the firm bottom edge, would also impact your breastbone. I have never seen any examples of that in any of the research I have done.....and I have done plenty. That’s not to say that under some bizarre circumstance it hasn’t happened, but under bizarre circumstances, full face helmets have caused severe neck injuries.
I stress that I am not talking about the old fashioned 3/4 helmets here, but the newer, extended cheekguard models. Maybe we should call them 7/8 helmets.
The 7/8 helmets provide me with significantly better vision (and I believe better vision on a motorbike is always safer vision) than full face helmets, and with the jury still out on exactly whether a full face is better than a 7/8 in preventing head trauma occasioning death, I do indeed believe I am indeed being “as safe as I can”, despite your intimation that using anything other than a full face or modular is not using “common sense”.
Pete
Yeah, in my opinion, the smartest helmet ever made, M109:thumbup:. Unfortunately, they changed the headshape between the series 2 and the series 3, and the 3 was too tight in the largest size they make.....bugger.....
Pete
Well crap, I have the first version. I hope it will still fit well then. I had that I don't have anywhere near me to try them on before hand. I have to buy then exchange, sometimes several times to get the correct one.
Here's another take on helmets I'm going to be 74 shortly and have been riding since I was 13. I spent a lot of time riding you know fun in the sun and live in south Texas and can ride everyday. I used mostly 3/4 helmets. My doctor noticed 5 spots of cancer on my face (you know fun in the sun). She recommended that I switch to a full face or modular.
I could get the series 3 on, but it was really tight in a couple of spots compared to the series 2. Way too tight that it would loosen a bit......and since I was wearing the largest size (XL), I couldn’t try the “next size up”, which may have been perfect. Boy, was I pissed. There I was, having found the perfect helmet for me, and suddenly it was gone once the Series 2 wore out.
Pete.
I have the XL as well and see they don't make an XXL........grrrrrrrrr
Make sure you try one on first, M109. Your head may be a different shape to mine and it may fit you perfectly. My brain is obviously much smaller than yours too, as I am both stupid AND dumb according to ofdave. Strangely, being insulted didn’t actually swing me around to his way of thinking :thumbup:
Pete
was not singling you out, stated my thoughts based on my experiences
what an ego to think I was specifically talking about you
It's your head and your life-you do what you feel is right for you-it's your decision, not mine.
I really don't give a rat's rear end.
Ofdave - “As far as riding wearing a modular with it being open-that's just stupid. They are not meant to be worn that way. Do a get off and have the open front get dragged on the ground and see what happens to your neck. Just dumb.”
Have a re-read of what you wrote above. I wore a modular Shark, sometimes open, which you say is “just stupid”. I ride with a 7/8 open face, which you say is “just dumb”. That means that you are indeed including me in your “general” insults above.
I, and others, have made a call based on well researched risk assessments for particular individual situations. You are of course entitled to a differing opinion, but to call those decisions stupid and dumb just because they don’t match your own beliefs says a great deal. Ego? My goodness :shocked:
Pete
I am not insulted when I read "differing opinions" from mine. Good grief, if we all felt that, our entire lives would be spent being insulted. My time on this planet is too short for me to be concerned with or feel insulted by every comment made which does not align with my take on a subject. Give that a try-you'll sleep better and smile more.
dave, I am NEVER insulted by someone’s differing opinion. I welcome them as they often provide more input to be considered. It’s just that I don’t believe those opinions need to include labels like “stupid” or “dumb” just because the opinion differs from your own.....unfortunately though, some people just can’t help themselves.......and it would be hard for me to laugh more and sleep better, so there’s no need to be concerned about that
Pete
if you had seen the face of the man injured wearing his half helmet, there is no doubt in my mind you would feel the same.
when I see behavior with disregard to the potential serious negative results for that behavior, I do not consider it sane, educated, intelligent, or reasonable and express my opinion accordingly.
Glad you sleep well, it is a treat.![]()