I have a standard because I just didn't trust the longevity of the automatic but the guy at the dealer says there have been no problems with the automatics (of course he's in sales and would say that). He went on to say that you could shift on the fly at any speed or rpm with no problem but honestly I find that hard to believe.
Has anyone got some insight on this? Is it true that you can abuse the automatics with no problems? I'm not a speed freak but I do tend to ride my Spyder pretty hard. The standard sucks it up and begs for more. Would the automatic?
Your question/thought is likely to solicit many responses from various experiences people have had with their Spyders.
The dealer's statement of being able to shift at any speed or rpm: not exactly an accurate statement, but not that far off.
For the most-part, you determine what gear you want by shifting. The automatic does not up-shift on its own. The SE5 does downshift once the RPM's get to a certain speed though.
Horsepower is an issue with some riders. Those being used to torque at the low-end are likely to complain about the "lack of horsepower" from the Spyder. Those who shift at higher RPM's (closer to or within the maximum power-band) will complain far less.
It comes down to the "riding-style" required of the Spyder to experience its fullest potential. If you don't ride the Spyder as it is designed to be, then you'll likely have a less desirable experience or opinion of it. Expecting a Spyder to have a V-Twin, or a "muscle-car" torque to it is assured to provide a dissatisfaction of the power and feel.
Regarding whether the SE5 is indestructible when being abused... Not sure what your version of abuse is. Anything made can be broken. Can you "get-on" the throttle of the SE5 and move? ...yes would be the answer; but it is NOT a drag-racer. It would be more aligned to an Italian performance car (not necessarily fast off the line, but down the stretch it will move).
The SE5 compared to the manual tranny... not sure whether it would be as quick. That would depend in part on the rider's skill. Personally, I have little problem with the power of the machine with the SE5.
(Keep in mind... weight has a lot to do with any vehicle's performance. If a person's size and luggage is close to the weight limit, or exceeds it... they should expect diminished performance -- period.)