Of course they'll recommend a 5-year replacement, they're tire manufacturers. I've been told 10 years is more realistic. I would venture a guess that there are many many more vehicles out there running 10+ year old tires than there adhering to the 5-year recommendation.
That guess might be correct, but it doesn't mean that running 10 y/o or older tires is a great idea or that it's always going to be safe to let your tires get that old!!

I also strongly doubt that you would've been told that 10 years is more realistic by any Tire Development, Design, &/or Testing Engineer, nor by anyone who really knows much about tires & the materials & compounds that get used in their manufacture!
Sure, a '
one size fits all' 5 year replacement policy might not be all that great for people who live in a relatively mild climate with no major extremes of temperature &/or large temperate fluctuations; who don't ever let their tires get 12+ hours of harsh sunlight or more in a day; &/or who don't ever push their tires to their limits (the tire's limits that is!

) but 5 years is a reasonably safe CYA Catch All policy for '
all tires' if you (the recommender

) don't really know the specific conditions that those tires are likely to be used/working in... even if some mildly used/exposed tires might get retired a little early - but at 5 years old, those tires that get used/exposed closer to their limits are probably either already at or beyond their safe usage/life, or going to be at least
nearing their end of safe usage/life, & the owner/operator definitely should be considering replacement!!
And at 5 years old, some of the High Performance tires that are readily available on the market today & feasibly might end up on a Spyder or an auto might be well beyond their 'safe usage/life', maybe even by 2 or 3 years if they've been worked hard/exposed to extreme temperatures/conditions! Heck, I've driven on & then retired 'road tires' that were '
too old for safe use' when they were
less than a year old, but they had been worked hard & seen some (orright, maybe it was a
lot of...) extreme temperature variations!
Still,
I'd guess that for
most Spyder Ryders/cage drivers who don't regularly ryde/drive at the limits of their tire's temperature capabilities; who don't leave their vehicles sitting exposed to weather extremes (especially the harsh/hot sun) all the time when not in use; and who don't usually let their tires experience exposure &/or use on too many days over 100°F/38°C, then 5 years old
might be juuust a tad soon to
arbitrarily retire their tires - but personally, even for those gentle users who always garage their vehicles when not actually driving them & who live in a mild climate, I'd still be
seriously thinking about replacing them before they went much past 7 years old...
But it is your Spyder... & your life, so it's your choice as & when to replace your tires!

Altho thinking about it a little further, it may also be the life of some other road user or maybe even that of a possibly innocent by-stander who just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time when that 5+ year old '
too old & shoulda been retired a year or 2 ago' tire finally gives up the ghost!

Only unless the vehicle burns fiercely & completely after the accident that takes someone out, leaving no tire residue
at all remaining for testing & dating, then any interested Investigators/Prosecutors will very likely be able to find out if not simply see & read the Date Code on the tire sidewalls, so if you want to keep running tires that are older than the generally accepted 5-7 years old, I guess you might want to ask yourself -
Are you really feeling that lucky??
Just Sayin'...
