The Scratch Resistant has been around for several years now offered in Dark Tint, Light Tint, and Clear. This was refereed to as New Generation for awhile but nobody knew what that meant either so we started telling customers it was Scratch Resistant which it is. Now when we say Scratch Resistant we don't mean that it won't scratch because it still may, the protective coating over it just helps lessen the chances. Also this is a poly-carbonate plastic instead of acrylic like the original wings. The poly carbonate is stronger than the acrylic and is less likely to crack or break if you was to kick it while mounting your Spyder. We have had customers who have had the acrylic for 20+ years and have had no troubles. So as mentioned above it really depends on preference of color, and looks. The acrylic will scratch fairly easy but this doesn't mean it will break it make just scratch if you go to clean them or a rock jumps up and hits them. If you have any other questions we could answer for you feel free to email us at
[email protected] Thank you for considering our product. Safe riding!