• There were many reasons for the change of the site software, the biggest was security. The age of the old software also meant no server updates for certain programs. There are many benefits to the new software, one of the biggest is the mobile functionality. Ill fix up some stuff in the coming days, we'll also try to get some of the old addons back or the data imported back into the site like the garage. To create a thread or to reply with a post is basically the same as it was in the prior software. The default style of the site is light colored, but i temporarily added a darker colored style, to change you can find a link at the bottom of the site.

A Non Owners Impression after eviewing Forum

Questions

New member
I want to start by saying that I am impressed by the loyalty to the Spyder shown by many on this forum. I do not own one at present and came on here to learn about the Spyder, warts and all. I think it is a great concept and I rode one of the preproduction models in July 07 and really liked it. I did not consider buying one at that time as the closest dealer was almost 300 miles from me. That being said let me tell you my observations and conclusions regarding the purchase of a Spyder.

My greatest concern has become it safety and reliablility. I have read about a lot of things failing that could lead to a catastrophic end under the wrong conditions. Examples are the power steering problems, failure or deterioration of wheel bearings, fuel lines routed to close to a hot engine, excess heat affecting the wiring and hoses under the tupperware,output shaft chewed up and metal paricles ending up in crankcase and fires on at least 5 spyders which currently are of unknown cause. Recognizing that these are new vehicles, in production only about 3 years problems are to be expected. But some of the above are too serious in my mind to ignore.

In addition there are other things that point to either lack of proper engineering or attempting to cut corners to reduce cost. Examples are failures of exhaust gasket at relatively low mileage, oil pump failures, oil sensor failures, mode button failures, cracking coolant reservoirs, defective radiator caps, and defects in evap cannister design resulting in strong fuel odors. People are still having problems with the emergency brake lever failing which was the case with the one I rode in 07. I would think they would have resolved that before now.

The last area of concern is the cost of operation. I am not a good mechanic and so can only do basic things like change oil and coolant. Due to the electronic wizardry of the Spyder much of the maintenance must be done at the dealer because they are the only ones who have the software to be able to do the necessary analysis. When I read of the cost of routine services, as much as $1100 for the 12k service I definitely have pause. I have never had to pay anything close to that kind of charge for a routine service on any vehicle I have ever owned. One person was charged $200 labor just to remount the rear tire. Yikes.

When I see a lot of low mileage Spyders up for sale I have to wonder why. I fully recognize that all the problems occur for a minority of owners but none the less some of the problems are too serious to overlook. I know some people probably do not find it a satisfactory replacement for a 2 wheeler but I also think there are other reasons.

In conclusion, as much as I like the Spyder I will not be buying one real soon. I will continue to monitor this forum and others sources and see if they get these bugs worked out. Then I will reevaluate my decision.

I hope nothing I have said here has offended anyone but I thought you might like to know what an outsider (non owner) thinks after reviewing your comments on this forum. I really wanted to be a Spyder owner and someday maybe I will be.
 
A fair analysis, based upon information gleaned from the forum... but I will continue to contend (both here and in OTHER brand forums to which I belong) that the majority of what you see in forums are problems; and basing a decision solely on forum content may be unduly biased towards the pessimistic - IMO forums do not provide the equivalent of unbiased reviews.

That said, I hope you find something that you are confident in and happy with for the long haul.
 
Last edited:
Reasonable analysis, and clear thinking, for your own values and perspective. I wish you the best of luck, finding a vehicle you shall enjoy.;)
 
Despite what may look like an overwhelming amount of trouble, the actual numbers of difficulties are still small, IMO. A forum usually publicizes trouble, while ignoring routine operation. There are some valid difficulties, though, and only you can determine if the risk is acceptable to you. Keep in mind that almost all vehicles have problem areas like this, but few have forums, so you just may not be aware of how many things break on an average Ford. I don't think the rate of failure is any higher on the Spyder than on anything else. I do think the Spyder electronics are overly sensitive and monitor more items. You don't really need to monitor for burned out bulbs, and certainly need no more than a warning if one goes out.

There are issues. The exhaust gaskets are crap. Definitely an engineering problem, probably compounded by a supplier problem. Goldwing gaskets are an alternative. The parking brakes have problems, but they can be repaired and maintaned afterward. Many owners do not even try to get them fixed. Ours was fixed and is dandy now. Some of the other issues you mentioned have been addressed by BRP, and are not present in the newer Spyders.

The maintenance schedule is rather picky, with some tasks that need to be performed more often that seems normal, like checking wheel bearings and replacing exhaust gaskets, flushing hydraulic fluids, etc. Maintenance often must be performed by the dealer due to the electronics, as on many modern vehicles, and that can be expensive. Only you can determine if you can afford it. It is on a par with my BMW, but it is not cheap.

Sorry you have elected not to purchase, I think you would have enjoyed the Spyder. In the end, however, this forum did exactly what it was supposed to do. It let you learn, and make an informed decision. my wife and I cruised the forums like you did, and studied before we bought. Everyone must evaluate the information at hand as it relates to their wants, needs, and finances, and go from there. Thanks for sharing your thoughts in a well worded, unemotional manner.
 
In conclusion, as much as I like the Spyder I will not be buying one real soon. I will continue to monitor this forum and others sources and see if they get these bugs worked out. Then I will reevaluate my decision.

I agree with QuadManic, "A fair analysis, based upon information gleaned from the forum". You have been paying attention and you laid out the issues both accurately and clearly.

I was faced with the same information and concerns (plus a couple of others you didn't mention), but came to a different decision, I purchased a Spyder. In the end, I worked out how I could manage the possible downsides and what risks I was willing to take. So far, so good. No regrets. More smiles than I ever imagined.

I did not make the decision lightly, nor did I discount the issues other had, but in a fair number of cases, their attitude and reaction were very different from what I would expect from me. I think it is always best when people make up their own minds and understand what the are doing. I try to and I respect others who do the same.

I do hope you keep it on the back burner and revisit it, but if it is not for you, I understand and fully support you in not getting a Spyder.

Tom
 
Personally, I have a Spyder that has been ABSOLUTELY trouble free. I think I am mainstream. You are seeing a very pessimistic and reactionary position on the forums.

Old Nixon had one thing right -- the silent majority . . .
 
Don't get one...saves more for us! :joke:

I want to start by saying that I am impressed by the loyalty to the Spyder shown by many on this forum. I do not own one at present and came on here to learn about the Spyder, warts and all. I think it is a great concept and I rode one of the preproduction models in July 07 and really liked it. I did not consider buying one at that time as the closest dealer was almost 300 miles from me. That being said let me tell you my observations and conclusions regarding the purchase of a Spyder.

My greatest concern has become it safety and reliablility. I have read about a lot of things failing that could lead to a catastrophic end under the wrong conditions. Examples are the power steering problems, failure or deterioration of wheel bearings, fuel lines routed to close to a hot engine, excess heat affecting the wiring and hoses under the tupperware,output shaft chewed up and metal paricles ending up in crankcase and fires on at least 5 spyders which currently are of unknown cause. Recognizing that these are new vehicles, in production only about 3 years problems are to be expected. But some of the above are too serious in my mind to ignore.

In addition there are other things that point to either lack of proper engineering or attempting to cut corners to reduce cost. Examples are failures of exhaust gasket at relatively low mileage, oil pump failures, oil sensor failures, mode button failures, cracking coolant reservoirs, defective radiator caps, and defects in evap cannister design resulting in strong fuel odors. People are still having problems with the emergency brake lever failing which was the case with the one I rode in 07. I would think they would have resolved that before now.

The last area of concern is the cost of operation. I am not a good mechanic and so can only do basic things like change oil and coolant. Due to the electronic wizardry of the Spyder much of the maintenance must be done at the dealer because they are the only ones who have the software to be able to do the necessary analysis. When I read of the cost of routine services, as much as $1100 for the 12k service I definitely have pause. I have never had to pay anything close to that kind of charge for a routine service on any vehicle I have ever owned. One person was charged $200 labor just to remount the rear tire. Yikes.

When I see a lot of low mileage Spyders up for sale I have to wonder why. I fully recognize that all the problems occur for a minority of owners but none the less some of the problems are too serious to overlook. I know some people probably do not find it a satisfactory replacement for a 2 wheeler but I also think there are other reasons.

In conclusion, as much as I like the Spyder I will not be buying one real soon. I will continue to monitor this forum and others sources and see if they get these bugs worked out. Then I will reevaluate my decision.

I hope nothing I have said here has offended anyone but I thought you might like to know what an outsider (non owner) thinks after reviewing your comments on this forum. I really wanted to be a Spyder owner and someday maybe I will be.
 
Personally, I have a Spyder that has been ABSOLUTELY trouble free. I think I am mainstream. You are seeing a very pessimistic and reactionary position on the forums.

Old Nixon had one thing right -- the silent majority . . .


Me too. My Spyder has been trouble free as well. I've been watching the posts lately and some folks are having some apparently serious problems. That's why we come to these forums, to seek knowledge from others. By the same token, you have to understand human nature and the vast majority of on-line posts IMHO, occur when problems occur. If the product you bought was running properly, you are out having fun and not bothering to post how you're not having any problems.

I think Bill and Trickie Dick were right about the silent majority. :doorag:
 
I only have 4000 miles on mine so far and have had just a few issues. One created by me with what I call careless driving and the other 2 were minor. I had the first year Hayabusa motorcycle with the failing aluminum subframes ( fixed by Suzuki), the first year B-king, which had some issues that were corrected by the company, so I usually figure the first few years that something new is manufactured, you may have some issues. This did not keep me from buying my 09 Spyder or ordering my 2010 RTS.
I have more fun on this Spyder than any of the last 4 motorcycles that I have or do still own. Its been great and its nice to jump on it and take off with no real destination and enjoy the ride. Its human nature for us to get caught up in the moment and find faults, but not as easy for us to praise companies for the good times thier products bring us. :spyder2::spyder2:
 
My 2 cents...

Howdy everyone!

Just wanted to speak up and say that I am a proud owner of my '09 SE5 Spyder with 11K miles and have had no issues.

I would also purchase another one in a heartbeat!

David
 
I strongly recommend that you go to BMWLT.com or GWRRA & read about the premiere two wheeled kings of the road today, the least expensive of which is over $20K, and has far more history and resources than the Spyder.

Remember, our instant information society magnifies every issue - many of which, we would have never heard of 3 to 5 years ago..
 
Me too. My Spyder has been trouble free as well. I've been watching the posts lately and some folks are having some apparently serious problems. That's why we come to these forums, to seek knowledge from others. By the same token, you have to understand human nature and the vast majority of on-line posts IMHO, occur when problems occur. If the product you bought was running properly, you are out having fun and not bothering to post how you're not having any problems.

I think Bill and Trickie Dick were right about the silent majority. :doorag:


Of all the different forums I visit that have to do with the products I own, this one is by far the most depressing. I didn't visit here for about a year and now that I'm back I get to read and catch up on all the horror stories concerning defective parts, computer malfunctions and the lack of dealer knowledge on the product they are selling. I own a 2008 Yamaha Raider motorcycle and a 2008 Suzuki GSX650F. When I visit their forums I enjoy reading about all the good times people are having with their machines instead of the crap so many Spyder owners are experiencing. Both these bikes were also first year products and yet problems are nearly non existant. If most of the posts on forums occur when there are problems, like several have suggested, the Yamaha and Suzuki forums would be ghost towns. This is not the case. People on those sites are busy talking about how happy and glad they are with their purchase. Like so many others, I have had problems with my Spyder and while I like the concept, I would never purchase another one. I'm hoping that someday a reputable company comes out with a similiar design minus all the defects......then I will be among the first in line to purchase one.
 
Understand your conclusion, but there are MANY happy owners out there that are rarely heard from. It's not all bad.
 
Not many problems here

I've had very little problems, I had to do the recall work, which always happens with newer vehicles anyway. That was something I expected when I bought the spyder. I had to have the emergency break fiddled with a bit, other than that I have had absolutely no problems. I would buy another one without any hesitation at all, the benefits outweigh the costs in my opinion. When you buy something there are always pros and cons, and you always have to spend money in up-keep. You have to ask yourself what is having the item worth to you. Of course, in some ways I'm glad some aren't buying the Spyder, I don't mind them being a rare novelty...makes it more fun to see expressions on other people's face when they see the bike, plus I have met so many people that I would have likely never talked to because people will approach to ask about it. I met some of my neighbors that ride bikes that way, and I have lived in this neighborhood for six years now!!

I guess I was just wondering why all this information is posted, I mean it is already posted somewhere else on the site. Are you trying to convince yourself you don't want one or trying to convince us? Good luck, I tried to convince myself I didn't want a Spyder and now I have one!!!!

I was expecting the review to talk about how on this site it seems people are polite, share knowledge readily with others, accept others opinions and whatever bike they ride (which we all know is not always the case with some other bikers), help others, don't bash each other, and though the bike might have problems they LOVE their spyder!! That is what I noticed about this website more than anything else. I know if I have a problem or am looking for a part, there is someone here that will have the answer or will point me in the right direction! :D
 
Last edited:
understand this... a lot of people use the forums as a way of sharing information... a lot of people share their concerns and frustrations and simply vent...
Not everyone writes about the good stuff...
If I was to write or post on how happy I am with my Spyder and how much joy I get from it, then I would have hundreds of post.
I do see how BRP can improve their product and I think they want to, but if you are going to wait for the product to be "perfect" to get one then just give up the idea of owning one...
Just get one, add the extra warranty (5years) and then enjoy the ride ! that is what I did...
 
Last edited:
understand this... a lot of people use the forums as a way of sharing information... a lot of people share their concers and frustrations and simply vent...
Not everyone writes about the good stuff...
If I was to write or post on how happy I am with my Spyder and how much joy I get from it, then I would have hundreds of post.
I do see how BRP can improve their product and I think they want to, but if you are going to wait for the product to be "perfect" to get one then just give up the idea of owning one...
Just get one, add the extra warranty (5years) and then enjoy the ride ! that is what I did...

Please consider the statement made above --

Not everyone writes about the good stuff...

and rethink it as

The vast majority does not write about the good stuff -- because they are not members here...
 
I appreciate the responses made by each of you. I currently have an 07 FJR 1300 and it is not perfect either but I have put 17k+ on it in the not quite 2 years I have owned it. There have been two recalls on it, one for an altitude problem with the ECU and ignition switch failures. I do not expect the Spyder to be perfect but I do want ot have confidence in what I ride. Riding is an inherantly dangerous activity as everyone knows. I do not want a machine that may malfunction and increase that danger.

In the time I have owned the FJR I have replaced tires once (about due again), and done the routine services and the two recalls. I have never had to leave the bike overnight due to lack of parts and the most expensive thing I have done is the tire changes. $50 labor to mount and balance each tire and less than $400 for both tires. The Yamaha dealer does charge by the book rate rather than actual hours but in my experience most shops do the same.

I get about 46-48 mpg on the FJR compared to the mid 20 to low 30's most of you seem to get on the Spyder. Both bikes weigh about the same and the FJR is 1300 cc compared to the 990 of the Spyder. I am sure wind resistance plays a factor with the wider frontal exposure of the Spyder.

I am sorry if my thread title was misleading as to the subject matter. I do find this forum to be more civil than either of the FJR forums I visit. But as mentioned by one person there are a lot more ride reports and positive threads on the FJR forum than on this one. I think part of that is due to the problems some have run into with their Spyder which results in them seeking advice with the problem or just venting.

I will continue to monitor this forum and I am glad so many of you are enjoying the Spyder. After all, enjoying the experience is what it is all about. Like I said before I may get a Spyder some day if I do not get to old to get on it first. Happy care free riding to all.
 
I've had very little problems, I had to do the recall work, which always happens with newer vehicles anyway. That was something I expected when I bought the spyder. I had to have the emergency break fiddled with a bit, other than that I have had absolutely no problems. I would buy another one without any hesitation at all, the benefits outweigh the costs in my opinion. When you buy something there are always pros and cons, and you always have to spend money in up-keep. You have to ask yourself what is having the item worth to you. Of course, in some ways I'm glad some aren't buying the Spyder, I don't mind them being a rare novelty...makes it more fun to see expressions on other people's face when they see the bike, plus I have met so many people that I would have likely never talked to because people will approach to ask about it. I met some of my neighbors that ride bikes that way, and I have lived in this neighborhood for six years now!!
As a Nubee I also have to agree with the above. Lots of good people and info here and pretty respectful..
I personally was starting to take flying lessons at $180 a hour and then one day it was to windy to fly, a saw the Spyder in person, took a trial ride and bought one within a week. I,m paying $217 a month for the lst year then social security will kick in a nd the Feds will pay the rest!! LOL
Now I,m flying a Spyder. I love it. The more you ride it and get used to it you start to feel like one with it. Its truely the Freedom machine and I :2thumbs:have been riding in 58-63 degrees with a lot of wind. Just wait till summer I,ll be out every afternoon!! ( When I,m not on my 2 Jet Skies flying down the river!!

I guess I was just wondering why all this information is posted, I mean it is already posted somewhere else on the site. Are you trying to convince yourself you don't want one or trying to convince us? Good luck, I tried to convince myself I didn't want a Spyder and now I have one!!!!

I was expecting the review to talk about how on this site it seems people are polite, share knowledge readily with others, accept others opinions and whatever bike they ride (which we all know is not always the case with some other bikers), help others, don't bash each other, and though the bike might have problems they LOVE their spyder!! That is what I noticed about this website more than anything else. I know if I have a problem or am looking for a part, there is someone here that will have the answer or will point me in the right direction! :D
:clap:
 
Back
Top