bikerbillone
Well-known member
Agree, if I just got out of the three wheel business, I'd find a nice rag top Miata to get the outside exposure. Those new one's are a sight to behold, but I reckon it would be a bit harsh on the budget.
Looked at both, rode/drove both and actually sold both a few years ago. I found the Slingshot to be a crude machine. Creaks/rattles/poor fit/unpolished. For the $$ though, it seemed like more of a no brainer over the Spyder. That said, the Slingshot takes up as much space as a automobile in the garage. As said above, find a good deal on a Miata. The Spyder has a more open air, motorcycle feel. When you ride with your two wheel buddies, you can actually park in a motorcycle spot, albeit just a touch more space. You don't have to look around for a auto stall. If physical limitations require a Slingshot, hell, go for it. I still prefer the airiness feel of the Spyder. As far as service issues, I don't feel like theirs a heck of a lot of differences between BRP/Polaris. My store was able to get support equally between the two.
I’ve owned 2 RT’s, an 11, and a 17. Loved both very much. Traded 11 for 17. Never had an ounce of trouble with 11. 17 has been nothing but trouble. Had it for a year and a half, been in shop half that time. Park brake acted up first week or so I had it, then straightened up for 6 months, then problem came back, had trouble with reverse button, computer went out, right cluster on handle bar had to be replaced. After getting all that fixed, thought and hoped everything and all my troubles were fixed and over. Went to Maggie Valley last week, noticed it was making an unusual noise, had rear tire put on, they said, uhoh, you have red dust on front pully. I was 500 miles fro home with a front pully problem. Didn’t even get to ride in mountains. They said it might get you back home, maybe not. Wife and I rented a slingshot there to ride in mountains, and see how it rode. Both of us liked it, RT did make it back home. Went to dealer that sold Canams and Slingshots. Wound up trading for one, my trust in Canams wasn’t there anymore. The 11, was flawless, the 17 was a never ending problem. I’m sure it’s not all, just that I got a bad one, we like to travel on it, and couldn’t trust taking it very far anymore. Maybe a Slingshots not going to be the right answer, maybe they aren’t anymore reliable, I’ll find out I guess. Sorry so long and windy. We liked the RT, just couldn’t trust it anymore
Welcome to the SS world. I have both, a 2018 RTL and a 2019 Slingshot SLR. I drove the SS home from Georgia to Colorado to get used to it.The two are not even comparable so all the defenses for the Spyder need not be there.
I am older than some and younger than others and I have no problem getting in or out of the SS (also do not have any problem getting on or off the RTL). It does sit low to the ground and has a ton of power, 173Hp and weighs 1750 Lbs without my butt in it. As far as the getting splashed it is a little bit wetter than the RT as you do not have as much air moving around to dry you off (like sitting in a convertible with the top down). But as for more stuff hitting you... have not noticed that.
I saw someone mention gas mileage... as has been stated here a bunch of times regarding the Spyder... "I didn't buy it for the gas mileage". That being said, if I do not put my foot into it all the time I get about 32mpg on the road and 30 in town.
There is more noise from the drive train of the Sling...(but I do not get the high pitch noise I get with the RT) it has to do with the angle drive... Once I changed the fluid the noise went away for the most part. If one lurks around the forums you will see all the complaints regarding the SS just as you do on the Spyder forums. The good and fun things do not get as much attention as the problems.... as was stated... sounds familiar. For storage, aftermarket is alive and well and makes the Spyder world look like a deal... Ex.. Corbin makes "saddlebags" which really look nice, but cost about $3500. There are solutions much less expensive... but that was just an example...
I find myself taking the SS more than the Spyder because (no offense meant to anyone) it is more fun. Recently coming home from Gunnison, CO and going over Monarch Pass (going up) where the speed limit is 35mph to 45mph... 70 and 75 were just plain fun and it held the road just like a sports car. To that end, I do consider it a car and not a bike like Polaris sells it. My understanding is they sell it as a bike so it does not have to meet car safety standards...For those who said they would rather have a Miata... well there is no comparison between the Miata and the SS either. The SS is just a bit more real feeling. The SS also has the Polaris Ride command unit which has all the features of the Can-Am Dash (except the Ride command is touch screen)... other than third party apps. Built in GPS, bluetooth, and massive stats for the machine. It connects to the mobile app just like the RT but gives you info... like recall and maint. schedules and the like. The main thing is that it is ready before you are ready to ride... no wait and you can update it yourself, no need to go to the dealer for updates. The 2020 SS is rumored to have a new power plant and will have an automatic trans... (I am guessing to get more people to look at them).
A word of advise... it does have a problem with hydroplaning... so if you get caught in a heavy rain with water sitting on the road... Slow down. It is not a problem with the machine, but the the size of the tires they put on it...
For reference (because I am sure someone will want to know) I have had 4 RT's, 2011, 2012, 2014 and the 2018. I like the RT no doubt and have well over 100k between the four. Problems... 2011 lots even left me stranded... 2012 a few fixe under warranty... 2014 one..DESS also fixed under warranty.. So far none on the 2018 but only have about 4k on it.
They are both great and fun machines, but other than both having 3 wheels there is no similarity.