I think we are missing some details that might help fill in some gaps here.
I bought an '09 in october with 8700 miles on it, and I paid almost 15k, however, it came with many additional options / aftermarket items I wanted.
(Corbin Fleetliners, Touring Windshield, Handlebar Risers, Additional lights, Highway Pegs (Kuriyakyn), Corbin Seat with 1 backrest) Those items added up very quickly to be more than the KBB value (again my opinion). Given then was it also received the 9k servicing before it came to live with me.
I am sure some people might disagree that this was a good or bad buy, but for me, having already had a lot of the optional after market items I wanted, I felt like the price was exceptionally good and I was pleased with my end result.
When the time comes to buy, you can "demand" or hope for KBB value or something near it, however, these are not like Toyota Camry's they are not just laying around being bought, sold, and traded every day. Given that, I think they command a mildly different market. Also given that, I dont think that Arntufun isn't WAY off base in his thinking, he is just an early commenter in the lifecycle of the product. Its similiar to buying toys now and not opening them in the hopes they increase in value, assuming BRP continues to improve, the market grows, and people embrace the spyder as an option to being on a motorcycle the situation COULD exist that his and other PE's would become more valuable, even if they are not now.