Insurance feedback, not a intended to be a price discussion.

[jcthorne]

I got my renewal from Progressive yesterday. I knew it was coming and I knew I was paying too much for Progressive. Flo just really wanted to push me to look elsewhere this year....

So I did. Got quotes for our two Spyder from a number of companies. All our other insurance (home, cars etc) is through State Farm. They told me to take the motorcycles elsewhere years ago as they know they are not competitive in that market. Checked yesterday and they still are not. They were more than Progressive, the highest quote of the day.

My quotes, from cheapest to most expensive line up like this:

Nationwide
Geico
Allstate
AARP/Foremost
Elephant / Merkel
Progressive
State Farm

I also checked with AARP/Hartford, Dairyland, Rider and they do not offer motorcycle coverage in Texas or did not have ratings for the Spyder.

Nationwide, Geico and Allstate are grouped withing a range of $100. Nationwide is actually offering the best policy with options like vanishing deductible, roadside assistance and $3k of accessories coverage that the others charge extra for or do not offer.

I am tempted to go ahead with Nationwide but I have never done business with them and am looking for some feedback from others that have. Also any words of wisdom on policy options we might have overlooked might be helpful. Please do not turn this into a 'my policy costs xxx' list.

And just for reference, Nationwide, Geico and Allstate are all 1/3 the price Progressive wants for the renewal...and we never filed a claim with Progressive since we started with them in 2008.

 

[Bob Denman]

Nationwide is a Company that has been around for years, and (up here!), their reputation is pretty solid.
Is the American Modern Home Group** selling in your State? I use them in my office, and they've been SUPER competitive in pricing, and just plain SUPER in claims service! :2thumbs:


** American Modern Home, American Family Home, American Reliable...

 

[2Paw]

effective today

I have Nationwide, the cost was about half what Dairyland wanted to renew my coverage. Discount for paying in full, being a AMA member, seems like a third one I can't remember. Dairyland has insured my RT in Texas for the last 2 years, your agent must not have looked hard enough. Not that it matters.

 

[jtoro1]

insurance

Check formost with AARP, good deal I had progressive.

 

[SPECTACUALR SPIDERMAN]

remember insurance is WORTHLESS until you need them so just do the number crunch they all pretty
much handle a claim the same way. all that matters is what they put down in writing that they give you.

 

[Big F]

I got my renewal from Progressive yesterday. I knew it was coming and I knew I was paying too much for Progressive. Flo just really wanted to push me to look elsewhere this year....

So I did. Got quotes for our two Spyder from a number of companies. All our other insurance (home, cars etc) is through State Farm. They told me to take the motorcycles elsewhere years ago as they know they are not competitive in that market. Checked yesterday and they still are not. They were more than Progressive, the highest quote of the day.

My quotes, from cheapest to most expensive line up like this:

Nationwide
Geico
Allstate
Elephant / Merkel
Progressive
State Farm

I also checked with AARP/Hartford, Dairyland, Rider and they do not offer motorcycle coverage in Texas or did not have ratings for the Spyder.

Nationwide, Geico and Allstate are grouped withing a range of $100. Nationwide is actually offering the best policy with options like vanishing deductible, roadside assistance and $3k of accessories coverage that the others charge extra for or do not offer.

I am tempted to go ahead with Nationwide but I have never done business with them and am looking for some feedback from others that have. Also any words of wisdom on policy options we might have overlooked might be helpful. Please do not turn this into a 'my policy costs xxx' list.

And just for reference, Nationwide, Geico and Allstate are all 1/3 the price Progressive wants for the renewal...and we never filed a claim with Progressive since we started with them in 2008.

Your discussion of insurance was timely as I'm currently doing a little shopping. Got my recent renewal from Allied Ins. and they raised my vanishing deductible but also raised the premium about 4% AND I had no claims.
BIG F

 

[granpa in Cincy]

Have you looked at Foremost? Others here have recomended them.

 

[one2doo]

I have Foremost with a $1000.00 deductible it only 249 a year on my F3

 

[SpyderAnn01]

Nationwide is on your side, right? I have Progressive and $3,000 of accessory coverage is included and that amount can be increased up to $10,000. They also offer replacement coverage for bikes that are no more than 2 model years old. With the rapid depreciation that Spyders seem to take that seemed to be a good bet. Would have come in handy on my 2013 if I had needed to use it after the fire.

 

[wyliec]

I found State Farm the least expensive. Of course I've been with them for 40 years. A pretty big factor, when pricing, is location.

 

[Bob Denman]

Please remember; Price means nothing... if the claims service isn't good! nojoke
The cheapest price may not get you the service that you need, if things get ugly! :shocked:

 

[Kwalsh]

i also have state farm , but i have it for homeowners,camper,suburban,wifes nissan and daughters toyota, i think full coverage is about $250 for the year

 

[jcthorne]

Ok, thanks for the suggestions so far. Just got a quote from Foremost/ AARP, they are cheaper than Progressive but more than the 3 best bids. In line with Merkel. Sent a request to American Modern, said they would have an agent contact me, no online quote.

 

[jcthorne]

i also have state farm , but i have it for homeowners,camper,suburban,wifes nissan and daughters toyota, i think full coverage is about $250 for the year

Odd. I have SF for the house and all other vehicles and they wanted near 1800 for the two spyders. Guess its Houston. So not an option for me.

 

[Dan McNally]

I've had GEICO for all my cars since I returned from Korea in 1983. When I got my Spyder, I went with them, as well. During those years, through multiple claims for vandalism, deer strikes, being rear-ended by uninsured driver, etc., they have always blown me away with their fast and very helpful service. They are not the very cheapest I can get, but they are within $100 a year of the best price I found, and that small amount is well worth the peace of mind to me, knowing that if there is an issue, I won't be involved in a fight to get compensated for my loss . . .

 

[jaherbst]

i also have state farm , but i have it for homeowners,camper,suburban,wifes nissan and daughters toyota, i think full coverage is about $250 for the year

When you quote a price it means nothing unless you quote the exact coverage that you have. We need to compare apples with apples. Full coverage does not mean much without exactly what is all covered. I have seen anywhere from $1000 to $250 which tells me we are not comparing the same things.

Jack

 

[Big F]

Your discussion of insurance was timely as I'm currently doing a little shopping. Got my recent renewal from Allied Ins. and they raised my vanishing deductible but also raised the premium about 4% AND I had no claims.
BIG F

I just noticed that the insurance I have with Allied Ins. is in fact a Nationwide company??? I have a 2014 RT Limited and the renewal was $373.65 annually. don't know if that is a good rate or not????

BIG F

 

[Kwalsh]

i meant for just the motorcycle when quoting price but i was more interested in the fact that you said state farm told you to take your bike elsewhere, this is my 3rd bike insured by them and they are very competitive with excellent coverage and claim service

 

[ARtraveler]

I found State Farm the least expensive. Of course I've been with them for 40 years. A pretty big factor, when pricing, is location.

Me Too with State Farm since 1965. They have all my vehicles and my home. They have always come through when I have put in a claim.

 

[Gator37]

IMHO I wouldn't ever buy Progressive Insurance. Would go without first. Check out their CEO and Connections.nojoke