Different strokes for different folks… choices are fun! I've had Russell, Corbin, Mustang, and other seats on my bikes, and none compare with the Corbin. I love the filler door, and have yet to spill a drop of fuel. I don't even have to get off the bike, if I don't want to, and only have to lift the seat to use a trickle charger (because I'm too lazy to wire a permanent solution…)