My 2 cents on this one. And I am probably overcharging!
There are 2 issues in play here.
#1 - Bearing Capacity
#2 - Belt Vibration
#1 is critical. Exceed the capabilities of the front or rear bearings and you're going to have failure. Catastrophic failure if it is the front counter shaft bearing. This is what drove the original belt tension reductions for the 2008-2012 models.
However, the lower belt tension specs. led to Issue #2. (Unintended consequence?)
#2 addresses customer complaints of 'excessive belt vibration'. The problem here is that 'Excessive' is a very subjective term. You might think that belt vibration on my Spyder is excessive. I think it is fine. But with the idea that 'The customer is always right', BRP has now transitioned from addressing Issue #1 to addressing Issue #2.
So how do you resolve the elusive issue of belt vibration. This is the Holy Grail that many (including BRP) are searching for. The only way to change (and possibly eliminate) belt vibration is to change belt tension or add a belt tensioner, which obviously BRP, to this point, is not interested in doing.
Since I assume that the previous upper belt tension limits were set to protect the bearings (Issue #1), the only adjustment option is DOWN.
So, I said all of that to say this. It is my feeling that this TST has nothing to do with Issue #1 and everything to do with Issue #2. You have to consider the poor dealerships with customers banging on their customer service desks demanding that something be done about belt vibration. Hence this TST is simply an option to try for those wanting to address Issue #2. And not a universal spec change.
In other words. If you're happy with the previous belt tension then I would forget about this TST. If your not, then give these new numbers a try.
I have no inside information and I may be completely wrong here. It would be great if BRP would clarify the issue. But if you are really having vibration issues and there is nothing mechanically wrong and everything is adjusted properly. A good belt tensioner is your only real solution. Because you could get everything adjusted just right, zero vibration, etc. Then load up for a trip 2-up, add your trailer and guess what. That vibration has come back because you've changed the parameters. A belt tensioner will compensate. A belt alone won't.
Good luck everyone! I am fortunate that my properly set belt using the previous (Pre-TST) numbers is just fine! :thumbup: