My wife drove both versions before buying. She noticed the strong clutch, but wanted to go with the manual enough to buy it. I also rode both and far preferred the feel of the manual. Of course, it's a personal preference, but we feel the manual has a better connection with the machine. Maybe if the SE shifted more like a DCT (BMW) or PDK (Porsche), the purchase would have been different. It just felt too mushy to us. It had nothing to do with the cost. Actually, our non-S had nothing to do with the cost, either......I would have paid more for the non-S than the S if we had to. (better grill, black frame, more pearl color, etc.)