Because:
Some people are just stubborn.
Some people don't understand proper English.
But mostly because people ASSume too much and fail to include details with their statements/claims.
"You should run XX pounds of pressure in your tires." Is a totally invalid and probably misleading statement.
To make it anywhere close to valid or useful, you must also mention the model of bike, the brand and type of tire and the normal load.
EVEN if you have said a thousand times before what bike and tires you have. People have short memories.
Exactly, and I apologize that I wasn't clear about that in an earlier statement.
Car tires have wide ranges of characteristics: sidewall stiffness, pliability, rubber compound, tread, weight, etc., etc., So blanket statements about car tires on motorcycles can be VERY different. "Butt", don't say anything about how it "feels." You will get an earful of pounding emojis and grand statements of "butt science."
When I went through my own "discovery" of where my PSI's should be, I started low. It's a common statement here, so I started there. Low pressures did NOT feel right, and my spyder was SLUGGISH. However, the more I bumped up the psi's in my Yokohamas for my 2015 RT Limited, the more I loved riding my Spyder. I made a comment about it last year and was HAMMERED about it by a particular poster here. He was an absolute a-hole about it and we got into it. Next thing I know he is bragging about his cherished "sanctioned drag race" win. Fun times!
I did my diligence of testing what I could do with pressures in the upper 20's. I rode for miles, stopped and took heat signature readings (as suggested from tire experts here,) and also tried stopping distances on wet pavement. I have a very long driveway, about 1000 feet. Now, I wasn't getting up highway speed, but I got a good idea of what it could stop with. Honestly, I didn't see much difference with the PSI as much as how I approached the stopping, i.e., the technique. I went to a big parking lot during a rain storm and did the same thing. It was the same. So, I feel VERY safe at 26psi up front and 28 psi in the back.
I tried 15psi and laughed trying to just turn it in my driveway. Might was well be stuck in mud. No way any one will convince me that 14-15psi is correct for my Yoko's and the way I ride. But that is the group think here, and that's OK, just don't be an a-hole about it.
Now, General Altimax: I have no clue. Haven't run them. I have extra rims and I may just buy some to work through the same workout. I have the stock Kendas on them, and it is NIGHT and DAY difference with 26psi in my Yoko's.