Yamaha has a 9.5-1 ratio and they warn not to use fuel below 91 octane in their new Raider motorcycle.
I can hear BRP's momma when it was growing up. "Now BRP," she says, with her hands on her hips, "Just because Yamaha jumped off a cliff, does that mean you should?"
Since this product seems to be squarely aimed at a market segment which values performance, it seems to me BRP would have specifically mentioned in the Spyder Operator's Guide any possible performance gains to be had using higher octane fuel. After all, GM did with the HHR...
Be that as it may, the manufacturer's guidance clearly says 87 octane is appropriate, and will not hurt your engine. Until we have hard DATA from a reputable source telling us otherwise, I think the manual remains our best guidance on fuel specification.
The fact that someone is experiencing pre-ignition or detonation with their Spyder using 87 octane gas does not indicate a requirement (in contradiction of the manual) for a higher octane. My troubleshooting would begin with the source of the gas -- it likely came from a bad batch. I would try filling up at a different station and see what happens.
If that doesn't fix it, I would assume a problem with the machine since the manual says I can use 87 octane. In my mind, a trip to the dealer would be the appropriate response. Using a higher octane gas might just mask a problem that could worsen if not attended to by a mechanic.
Remember the saying "penny wise and pound foolish" I opt for the extra 20-25 cents per gallon and use premium at every fill up.
Believe me, if the extra buck-and-a-quarter made me "feel" better about it, I would fill up with Premium everytime and ryde with a smile. :2thumbs: My daughter pays ten bucks a bottle for "salon grade" shampoo -- I use 98-cent-a-bottle Suave from Wally-world. But that's ok, because it makes her feel good about herself. (Come to think of it, maybe that's why my hair is falling out...)
For me, I know if I filled up the Spyder (or my Honda Accord for that matter) with Premium, all I would feel is a little sheepish for paying for something I don't need.
Regards,
Mark