2 wheel GL1800 Goldwing vs Spyder fun factor question?

[bug's zedi]

After an unintentional get off of our wing, my wife and I are considering our options. I know that we are comparing apples and grapes, and that they are completely different types of vehicles, but the two have enough in common for our purpose.

We currently ride an 08 2 wheel Goldwing which we have upgraded with arguably the best suspension available for the wing (Full mega monte Traxxion $2,800). We ride two up exclusively and in the twisty WV mountains whenever we can. We always obey the laws of physics (well until lately), but consider those pesky mph signs as a nuisance. Straight line top speed not important, but speed in curves is. We are usually 15-20+ over recommended. We have ridden with some very respected good riders, and though we could not keep up when they ran hard, we were still not holding up the group as a whole. Figure somewhere around 7 out of 10 in riding ability overall with consistency being our weak point.
Having said all that, I have some questions about comparing the 2 wheel Wing and Spyder.

Fun Factor:
I know that the experience, and ride is very different, but for overall fun pushing each hard in the twisties, how do they compare in overall fun, and how often does the nanny spoil that fun?

Performance:
Given riders of equal abilities in the 7+ range, how well would a Spyder with the best available off the shelf suspension keep up with a 2 wheel wing in twisty mountain roads? Would it keep up, be able to keep the wing in sight, not be embarrassingly behind, or would the wing rider be waiting on the other side of the mountain sipping coffee after he gassed up?

How much would a complete suspension upgrade cost?

How would 500+ pounds of passenger and rider change the comparison?

Thanks for your insights

 

[jerpinoy]

:welcome: First of all thank you in posting, You may need to evaluate the spyder, try to rent one and experience what we have. Then you can decide the best for you. Like others I have fun in my :spyder2:in many different ways.

Keep reading all the post of our member and learn from them, I did. Good luck and Ride safe and have fun.:yes:

 

[Bob Denman]

You cannot fairly compare a motorcycle to a trike...
It's a bit like comparing slingshots and pianos... :shocked:
But :welcome:anyway! :thumbup:

 

[cuznjohn]

goldwing

After an unintentional get off of our wing, my wife and I are considering our options. I know that we are comparing apples and grapes, and that they are completely different types of vehicles, but the two have enough in common for our purpose.

We currently ride an 08 2 wheel Goldwing which we have upgraded with arguably the best suspension available for the wing (Full mega monte Traxxion $2,800). We ride two up exclusively and in the twisty WV mountains whenever we can. We always obey the laws of physics (well until lately), but consider those pesky mph signs as a nuisance. Straight line top speed not important, but speed in curves is. We are usually 15-20+ over recommended. We have ridden with some very respected good riders, and though we could not keep up when they ran hard, we were still not holding up the group as a whole. Figure somewhere around 7 out of 10 in riding ability overall with consistency being our weak point.
Having said all that, I have some questions about comparing the 2 wheel Wing and Spyder.

Fun Factor:
I know that the experience, and ride is very different, but for overall fun pushing each hard in the twisties, how do they compare in overall fun, and how often does the nanny spoil that fun?

Performance:
Given riders of equal abilities in the 7+ range, how well would a Spyder with the best available off the shelf suspension keep up with a 2 wheel wing in twisty mountain roads? Would it keep up, be able to keep the wing in sight, not be embarrassingly behind, or would the wing rider be waiting on the other side of the mountain sipping coffee after he gassed up?

How much would a complete suspension upgrade cost?

How would 500+ pounds of passenger and rider change the comparison?

Thanks for your insights

i traded in my 08 wing that i loved for a 12 BMW k1600 gtl. not the wing was a great bike and i think it handled great. the BMW i think handled better than the wing and everyone i rode with said that i handeled it better than the wing. i had to sell the BMW due to health issues with my diabetes and my feet. i was afraid that putting my feet down one day i might drop the bike, i didn't want to give up riding so i bought a 13 spyder rt/s with all the bells and whistles. first i will say the spyder takes getting used to, it is not a wing. i am enjoying riding it but i do have a hard time keeping up with friends due to the insecurities i still have but i am sure for the most part i will get over that being i don't ride that much in the heat. i think it would handle the 500 pounds with no problem, me being 300 + pounds myself and it handles great.
others will have to help you with the cost of the upgrades but i spent 695 on the elka shocks and around 200 on the baharon sway bar. it rt/s already has the air suspension. so good luck and if you are going to keep the wing it will make a nice change off every now and than.

 

[viperryder]

Three wheel vers two wheels

After an unintentional get off of our wing, my wife and I are considering our options. I know that we are comparing apples and grapes, and that they are completely different types of vehicles, but the two have enough in common for our purpose.

We currently ride an 08 2 wheel Goldwing which we have upgraded with arguably the best suspension available for the wing (Full mega monte Traxxion $2,800). We ride two up exclusively and in the twisty WV mountains whenever we can. We always obey the laws of physics (well until lately), but consider those pesky mph signs as a nuisance. Straight line top speed not important, but speed in curves is. We are usually 15-20+ over recommended. We have ridden with some very respected good riders, and though we could not keep up when they ran hard, we were still not holding up the group as a whole. Figure somewhere around 7 out of 10 in riding ability overall with consistency being our weak point.
Having said all that, I have some questions about comparing the 2 wheel Wing and Spyder.

Fun Factor:
I know that the experience, and ride is very different, but for overall fun pushing each hard in the twisties, how do they compare in overall fun, and how often does the nanny spoil that fun?

Performance:
Given riders of equal abilities in the 7+ range, how well would a Spyder with the best available off the shelf suspension keep up with a 2 wheel wing in twisty mountain roads? Would it keep up, be able to keep the wing in sight, not be embarrassingly behind, or would the wing rider be waiting on the other side of the mountain sipping coffee after he gassed up?

How much would a complete suspension upgrade cost?

How would 500+ pounds of passenger and rider change the comparison?

Thanks for your insights

I too had a 09 Wing. At first was not sure how to ryde, but have learned very quickly, as will you. The Spyder will keep up with just about all two wheeled bikes. My wife and I ryde together all the time and we have no problems keeping up with other bikes or Spyders. Next question. I have added an after market sway bar, which you could, and it makes 100% difference in the ryde. Hope this helps.

 

[Highwayman2013]

If you can rent a Spyder that would be the best way to try one. Otherwise get a test drive from a dealer. The first time I rode a spyder was at a dealer event and I was hooked, I told my wife about them and she wanted her own so I bought her a 2012 RT Limited. I put on the swaybar and can hustle it very well in the twisties. I have a two wheeler and my wife rides the Spyder. My wife had no trouble keeping up with me on our vacation to WV. Wow they have some curvy roads. Good Luck on your choice.

 

[Dan_Ashley]

After an unintentional get off of our wing, my wife and I are considering our options. I know that we are comparing apples and grapes, and that they are completely different types of vehicles, but the two have enough in common for our purpose.

We currently ride an 08 2 wheel Goldwing which we have upgraded with arguably the best suspension available for the wing (Full mega monte Traxxion $2,800). We ride two up exclusively and in the twisty WV mountains whenever we can. We always obey the laws of physics (well until lately), but consider those pesky mph signs as a nuisance. Straight line top speed not important, but speed in curves is. We are usually 15-20+ over recommended. We have ridden with some very respected good riders, and though we could not keep up when they ran hard, we were still not holding up the group as a whole. Figure somewhere around 7 out of 10 in riding ability overall with consistency being our weak point.
Having said all that, I have some questions about comparing the 2 wheel Wing and Spyder.

Fun Factor:
I know that the experience, and ride is very different, but for overall fun pushing each hard in the twisties, how do they compare in overall fun, and how often does the nanny spoil that fun?

Performance:
Given riders of equal abilities in the 7+ range, how well would a Spyder with the best available off the shelf suspension keep up with a 2 wheel wing in twisty mountain roads? Would it keep up, be able to keep the wing in sight, not be embarrassingly behind, or would the wing rider be waiting on the other side of the mountain sipping coffee after he gassed up?

How much would a complete suspension upgrade cost?

How would 500+ pounds of passenger and rider change the comparison?

Thanks for your insights

2 Wheeler..3 wheeler...not the same...similarities, but not the same. If you are looking for the same, you need to stay with the same...I've ridden 2 wheelers for about 38 years. Went down once--my fault.

I think the Spyder is a much better machine, but it took me 2,000 miles to get used to its pecularities. I never plan on going back....and, by the way, I did not make the switch because of any health, or balance reasons. I made the switch because I just wanted to do so. So, rent one for 500 to 1,000 miles. Then decide. Other options I researched: Goldwing trike, BMW dual sport with sidecar, Harley trike, Lehman aftermarket kit on my victory. I chose the Spyder because I liked it best.

 

[bug's zedi]

You cannot fairly compare a motorcycle to a trike...
It's a bit like comparing slingshots and painos... :shocked:
But :welcome:anyway! :thumbup:

I do understand that, but even slingshots and pianos have comparrison points.

Fun Factor: Ask any 10 year old boy and he will tell you which is more fun.

I am sure there are a few here who ride in mixed groups who can opine on riding a given route how would one stack up against the other given equal riders and the urge to do it quickly. I am not looking for a fair comparrison, only a relative one. If people here say that you lose all the fun factor, and even hold up the harley riders in the twisties, then I know not to pursue any further. If they say it is about as fun, but different, and it holds it own in speed from point a to point b in the mountains, then I know it is a possibility to look at. That is all I am looking for

Not looking for the same experience, only the same fun factor and hustling through the twisties is an important part of that.

 

[CurtG]

Last May on the way to Rolling Thunder three of us 2 Spyders and a Harley Dresser ran across US 50 through WVa in the rain. My first long trip and certainly my first trip on twisties like that. It was and interesting and fun morning in the mountains and our Harley friend wasn't complaining about the pace. I'd do it again, hopefully on a sunny day .

Ride and ride safe,

 

[MouthPiece]

You cannot fairly compare a motorcycle to a trike...
It's a bit like comparing slingshots and painos... :shocked:
But :welcome:anyway! :thumbup:

I'm like Bob. It's like comparing oranges to apples or as I've said before Marilyn Monroe to Jane Russel.
Or for you younger whipper snappers Demi Moore to Melony Griffin? :yikes:

Chris

 

[arntufun]

I do understand that, but even slingshots and pianos have comparrison points.

Fun Factor: Ask any 10 year old boy and he will tell you which is more fun.

I am sure there are a few here who ride in mixed groups who can opine on riding a given route how would one stack up against the other given equal riders and the urge to do it quickly. I am not looking for a fair comparrison, only a relative one. If people here say that you lose all the fun factor, and even hold up the harley riders in the twisties, then I know not to pursue any further. If they say it is about as fun, but different, and it holds it own in speed from point a to point b in the mountains, then I know it is a possibility to look at. That is all I am looking for

Not looking for the same experience, only the same fun factor and hustling through the twisties is an important part of that.

To me the Spyder much more fun than any two wheeler. While your trying to avoid sand, leaves, gravel ect....... we keep on truckin enjoying the view not looking for road hazards. You said it yourself that you took a spill, I don't see any fun factor in that. Anyone who tells you that you will lose the fun factor on a Spyder have no clue what they are talking about.


I'm not trying to be rude but, you seem to have this mis-understanding that the Spyder could not keep up with your Wing in the Twisties. I'm not sure where you got this information from, but it can't be further from the truth.

My advise to you is pull over if a Spyder is coming up behind your Wing or your Harley friends in the twisties because you most likely will be going to slow for them.

Whatever you decide to buy, thanks for checking out the Spyder. It's a wicked nice ride with even a nicer group of owners. :thumbup:

 

[fyrertuck]

Great write up.

First I am going to turn 50 this year and I have been riding a GW for the past 19 years. I have had 3 bad motorcycle accidents. In 2012 my wife and I said it was time to trike.

Well I will cut this short. I have a 2012 Spyder RT SE5 and love it. I can run down any 2 wheel on the road with my Spyder.

I will say you should rent one and keep an open mind on how it runs.

Good luck in what you buy.

 

[Tx web rider]

comparison

i ride with a good friend who rides a 2009 gw1800 we recently went and did the twisted sisters ride a couple times first was in a light drizzle and second was dry

for information the sisters is a trio of twisted hilly roads that span 128 miles to do the entire ride.

with high inclines steep side walls extremely sharp turns that often carry debris off the side walls in the roads of course there are strait runs also

i was in the lead on my 2009 spyder rs (stock all the way drive line and suspension running car tires) with Tom behind on the gw

on the average on damp roads i was still over the posted speed a lot in the turns

the spyder does not take the fun out of the twisties it does take away some of the danger factor of falling over

i do admit the up hill hard twisties i would pull away from Tom and the downhill he would be all up me the spyder handles a powered uphill twisted climb like a mountain goat strong and sure footed the downhill same turns tend to be a little less surefooted

gw1800 has a lot higher top end than the rs and faster acceleration but the spyder has enough power and speed to out run most of the harleys out there

the second trip through the sisters we were both pulling cargo trailers and we were still over the posted speed limits most of the time

hope this helps i never rode a 2 wheeler but i ride a spyder like a mad man on 3 wheels like tom says i ride my 998 cc very hard and love it

 

[jthornton]

I own a 2009 GL1800 and a 2012 RT-S and ride both regularly. I have stock everything on the Goldwing and added Elka Stage 1+, BajaRon Swaybar and Pitt Bull Shock Relocators to the RT-S. The stock 2012 RT-S IMHO was mushy and rolled too much in the curves and the wife felt like she was being launched off the back at each turn and hated riding the Spyder... add the BajaRon Swaybar and like night and day she liked riding the Spyder as much as the Goldwing. I'm 60 and don't care to push either bike when riding 2 up (it hurts my ribs). You do focus on different things when riding each bike in the twisties. By my self I can make the Nanny put the brakes on in a corner. You will want to try all models of the Spyder to see which one suits your riding style.

Go to a Spyder event and you will get information overload and meet a bunch of nice people.

JT

 

[Pennyrick]

Fun Factor:
I know that the experience, and ride is very different, but for overall fun pushing each hard in the twisties, how do they compare in overall fun, and how often does the nanny spoil that fun?

Performance:
Given riders of equal abilities in the 7+ range, how well would a Spyder with the best available off the shelf suspension keep up with a 2 wheel wing in twisty mountain roads? Would it keep up, be able to keep the wing in sight, not be embarrassingly behind, or would the wing rider be waiting on the other side of the mountain sipping coffee after he gassed up?

How much would a complete suspension upgrade cost?

How would 500+ pounds of passenger and rider change the comparison?

Thanks for your insights

My wife and I both have '12 Spyder RT's. She used to ride a Suzuki and I used to ride a GL1800. There is a world of difference between riding on two wheels versus three, whether the third wheel be located on back or front. I triked the GL but was never happy on twisty roads as it 'plowed' in the turns despite a 6 degree rake to make it easier to steer.

She was first to take to the Spyder and after trying and failing to keep up with her on trips through the mountains, I finally bought one too. There is no question that it takes at least 750 or more miles to get into a comfort zone with the Spyder and trust it to go where you want to put it but even at my (somewhat) advanced age, I still think I could out corner myself back in the two wheel days.

You just have to try it out and that is hard to do because I am not aware of any dealer that will let you test a machine for that many miles. It is a big investment to make. You are just going to have to trust some of the comments on this board and then make a decision.

 

[Showie]

Fun is in the experience! If you are always worried about putting the bike down I don't believe that is fun! Exciting yes. Spyder can be fun and as exciting as you want without all the worries.

 

[ARtraveler]

Welcome to the forum.

:ani29:: A test drive is strongly recommended to see if the :spyder2: is going to be a good match for you and the missus. I recommend the RT model since it is most like what you are currently used to.

:ani29:: You are comparing apples to whatever--so they are not an exact match.

:ani29:: There is a learning curve on driving a :spyder2:, so I do not recommend putting it through the paces until you are ready. The :spyder2: will easily go 15 to 20 plus posted on most curves and will be able to keep up with or even outdo the performance of some other big tourers. Gas mileage is not going to be as good as you are used to though.

:ani29:: RE: suspension. That is a personal call and I would not do any suspension upgrades until you get used to the OEM specs. Some people swear by suspension upgrades and some (like myself) are perfectly happy with the :spyder2: as it is.

Let us know what you decide.

 

[Pirate looks at --]

Wad He Say

I'm like Bob. It's like comparing oranges to apples or as I've said before Marilyn Monroe to Jane Russel.
Or for you younger whipper snappers Demi Moore to Melony Griffin? :yikes:

Chris

...ah young whipper snappers would be Miley Cyrus to Lindsey Lohan!:roflblack:

 

[cbell1]

One thing that hasn't been mentioned is that the Spyder is a rev happy engine. If you have the opportunity to rent a Spyder for a week end, up shift at 5K or above and down shift no lower than 4K especially if you rent the SE5 version. Keep the revs up and the power isn't too bad once you get used to it. Coming from a GL1800 you may initially think the Spyder is severely under powered. Cruise at 5K-6K rpm.

 

[MouthPiece]

...ah young whipper snappers would be Miley Cyrus to Lindsey Lohan!:roflblack:

You're absolutely right although I have hit that stage that I just don't look at any under 30.

Chris