Mine worked great! I have the Shad 58x so it expands quite a bit. I used it for our cross country trip this summer, and I really liked being able to use the case like a suitcase, though when we were staying somewhere for only a single night, I tended to leave it on and just pull stuff from it.
The only issue is putting the bracket for the Shad box on the Baker Built rack. It wasn't hard, but I sort of fiddled around with a bunch of things before I felt it was secure. The brackets that came with the Shad didn't work well—we had to straighten them out a bit to stretch across the gaps in the Baker Built rack. But, it has stayed put for 7,000 miles, so it worked okay.
The first two pics show the Shad in place (please ignore the dust from my dirt road). The last pic is from our trip, and you can see the Shad mounting bracket on the Baker Built rack.
Reply With Quote
