PDA

View Full Version : intermittant vibrations @ highway speeds



MONK
03-08-2020, 08:48 PM
Went on my 1st real ride at highway speeds today (about 70 miles of 65-75mph). Intermittantly, I'd get a vibration that felt like a really rough road (not like potholes rough but like...just rough). I could feel the vibrations in the floorboards. I've driven this stretch of road literally thousands of miles in the past couple of years and I don't recall (nor did I see) and bad sections of road. Definitely vibrations. More concerned since the Spyder only has about 650 miles on her.

If it had been a steady vibration, I'd have said it was a very unbalanced tire.

What say ye, fine citizens?

Peacekeeper6
03-08-2020, 09:19 PM
Went on my 1st real ride at highway speeds today (about 70 miles of 65-75mph). Intermittantly, I'd get a vibration that felt like a really rough road (not like potholes rough but like...just rough). I could feel the vibrations in the floorboards. I've driven this stretch of road literally thousands of miles in the past couple of years and I don't recall (nor did I see) and bad sections of road. Definitely vibrations. More concerned since the Spyder only has about 650 miles on her.

If it had been a steady vibration, I'd have said it was a very unbalanced tire.

What say ye, fine citizens?

There’s a reason why they make/sell belt tensioners.

BLUEKNIGHT911
03-08-2020, 09:34 PM
Since you state it 's " intermittent " ….. I have noticed similar feelings on my Spyder on roads that I don't feel anything if other types of vehicles …. my thoughts are : a lighter weight vehicle is more susceptible to the type of " road surface texture " than heavier veh's ….. hopeing it 's not something mechanical ….. but that would be purely on guess based on what you have described. ….. I really can't see how the lack of a BELT tensioner could be the issue …. I don't have one and have no vibes …. but my belt is a bit looser than the spec …… good luck …. Mike :ohyea:

RICZ
03-08-2020, 09:40 PM
If the belt tension is to BRP specs, it might need to be loosened a bit. Or it might be too loose - have you checked the tension?

MONK
03-08-2020, 10:06 PM
Blue knight, I thought about that but I've ridden the same road on a 2 wheel bike and never felt that.

I have no idea about the belt tension. How would I check it? The dealer checked it last week and said it was good so bringing it back to him wouldn't help. I've ridden @ 60mph on other roads and didn't feel anything so if it's belt tension, could that only happen @ a certain speed and why not all the time @ that speed?

2dogs
03-08-2020, 10:24 PM
Ask the tech to set the belt tension on the lower side of the scale. If the vibration is still present and it moves according to where it was before (speed wise) , then you'll know what the problem is.

RICZ
03-08-2020, 11:16 PM
I had to relax my belt 40 pounds from what the "tech" had it at. You use a Kriket to accomplish that. They are available on eBay and Amazon. Get one that reads no higher than 200 pounds.
Forget how your two wheeler felt. A Spyder has a completely different road feel.

Woodaddict
03-09-2020, 12:55 AM
I can live with intermittent vibes. I can get them from going over a bump in road triggers it for a while, then goes away. Didn't want to put belt tensioner on it, and goes bad and ruins belt. I did set my belt to 160 on kriket gage

PinkRosePetal
03-09-2020, 03:16 PM
Went on my 1st real ride at highway speeds today (about 70 miles of 65-75mph). Intermittantly, I'd get a vibration that felt like a really rough road (not like potholes rough but like...just rough). I could feel the vibrations in the floorboards. I've driven this stretch of road literally thousands of miles in the past couple of years and I don't recall (nor did I see) and bad sections of road. Definitely vibrations. More concerned since the Spyder only has about 650 miles on her.

If it had been a steady vibration, I'd have said it was a very unbalanced tire.

What say ye, fine citizens?Two possibilities, both drive belt vibration. You've got a vibrating version of the Spyder or you've got a stone chip jammed between the sprocket teeth. Have you passed over any new road surfacing, tar and chippings, recently? Why it produces an intermittent vibration I've no idea but it certainly does and it feels like a stone stuck in a tyre tread. However, much more likely it's a viby bike. Typically at 70-74mph. We run two 2017RT one vibrates, the other doesn't and never has. It's worse in a side wind on the vibrating bike. Slackening the belt considerably does help but you may still get some vibration but at a lower speed. There is a secondary benefit to having a belt set loose, if you are unlucky enough to get a stone chipping caught between the belt and the sprocket, the slacker belt has enough stretch to lift over it without damage. Don't ask how I know this...

MONK
03-09-2020, 07:55 PM
Thanks, all. I don't have a garage, lift or large tools to loosen the axle bolt/nut (I think I read 36mm?). I think I'll call the dealership tomorrow and ask the wrench/tech how he checks the belt tension. If he says he uses one of those krikit gauges, I'll ask what he tightens the belts to and see if he can loosen it up a bit. Shouldn't take but a few minutes for someone well qualified w/the right tools, I'd think. If he says he uses the "thumb guage" method, I'll find another dealer. :)

PinkRosePetal---Never knew some of these were prone to bad vibes. It's not the end of the world as long as something isn't mechanically wrong, just annoying as all get out. Haven't been on any newly chipped roads so I'm just guessing I didn't get anything in the belt.

Woodaddict---We'll have to get together and ride sometime. I met a nice fellow SpyderLover member a couple weeks ago (JayBros) who lives down around Charlotte, I think.

h0gr1der
03-09-2020, 08:29 PM
Mr Monk,
My Spyder had a harsh vibration from the showroom floor. It occurred at the start of a hill, or when changing throttle to a light load. Very load dependent. After much gnashing of teeth and reading, I bought a Krikit II and tools to set my tension to the lower specs. I stair stepped my way down to the absolute minimum spec referenced in the belt tension service memo, and it almost completely eliminated my vibrations. I did install a belt dampener, but removed it when a few of the rollers failed. The vibration got less frequent and lower intensity the lower I went on the tension. Don't expect the dealer to set the tension to the lowest spec, for the most part they are stuck on stupid about the specification listed at the front of the manual, and not the revised spec in the service bulletin or in the Technical Specs section of the manual. If you have any mechanical aptitude setting the tension and aligning the rear wheel is about a 30-45 minute job, requires minimal tools also.

MONK
03-09-2020, 10:21 PM
Mr Monk,
My Spyder had a harsh vibration from the showroom floor. It occurred at the start of a hill, or when changing throttle to a light load. Very load dependent. After much gnashing of teeth and reading, I bought a Krikit II and tools to set my tension to the lower specs. I stair stepped my way down to the absolute minimum spec referenced in the belt tension service memo, and it almost completely eliminated my vibrations. I did install a belt dampener, but removed it when a few of the rollers failed. The vibration got less frequent and lower intensity the lower I went on the tension. Don't expect the dealer to set the tension to the lowest spec, for the most part they are stuck on stupid about the specification listed at the front of the manual, and not the revised spec in the service bulletin or in the Technical Specs section of the manual. If you have any mechanical aptitude setting the tension and aligning the rear wheel is about a 30-45 minute job, requires minimal tools also.

:( I don't. :(

I understand the basics of adjusting the belt tension. I had a belt drive on my Victory Vision but I had a lift and a garage when I had that. I have almost no tools anymore and no garage/carport. I guess I can look around to see if any of my coworkers has a garage and tools I could borrow for an hour.

Any idea what the tension range is for a 2018 RTL?

Woodaddict
03-09-2020, 11:10 PM
Woodaddict---We'll have to get together and ride sometime. I met a nice fellow SpyderLover member a couple weeks ago (JayBros) who lives down around Charlotte, I think.

yes we will. currently very busy for another 2 months, building a house. sometime in June or after. I do have a daughter that lives in Wilkesboro. Have not yet met Jaybros. The closest Spyder I have met is Norwood, just 1 time

Wahrsuul
03-10-2020, 06:12 AM
I have tools and a carport - or maybe my brother's shop. I don't have a tension gauge though. Probably ought to get one as I think I get the same vibrations you're talking about - comes and goes and feels like a rough/gravel road but not really steady. I need a new set of tires and was thinking I might try to check the belt at the same time.

How far is Wilkesboro from Columbia?

Woodaddict
03-10-2020, 06:35 AM
how far is wilkesboro from columbia?

about 3 hrs, right up I77. I have the kriket gage, could come to my house, save 1.25 hrs, if we could work it out

Woodaddict
03-10-2020, 07:58 AM
Monk, why don't you just skip dealership, come to my house, for kriket party? I have 36 mm socket, torque wrench. I have already had my rear wheel off for new tire.

forecast for Friday is rain, if we get too much, I don't have any work on new house as it would be a haul dirt in wheel barrow day. so Saturday might work out if you can come, might be a last minute decision.

hey Wahrsuul come on up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I try to do most of my Spyder and bike easy maintenance. I call this easy

rain date could be sunday afternoon

larryd
03-10-2020, 08:20 AM
I can live with intermittent vibes. I can get them from going over a bump in road triggers it for a while, then goes away. Didn't want to put belt tensioner on it, and goes bad and ruins belt. I did set my belt to 160 on kriket gage

Think about one of these belt tensioner's...(https://www.smoothspyder.com/) Forum sponsor and they LAST...

Woodaddict
03-10-2020, 08:25 AM
nope don't need one. thanks. for me its a waste of money, only once in a while vibes. is any spyder perfect???? I can live with a 98% spyder

h0gr1der
03-10-2020, 11:51 AM
Here are a couple of pictures for the belt tension. One is the TST from 2015, the other is from the Technical Specifications at the rear of my service manual. You will see that the tensions can be set considerably lower than the dealerships say. You hve to convert Newtons to Pounds. The Krikits measure in pounds. Make sure you use a known good converter, I ran across one that gave false answers.

179423

179424

Navydad
03-10-2020, 08:35 PM
I'm one of the rare birds who had to increase tension just a bit to get a smooth ride. My belt was 160 on the Kriket with the wheel on the ground and I got bad vibs from 55 to 65 MPH. I kept lowering the tension and test riding until I was down to 120 and still had vibes. Gave it a shot going the other direction and with the tension at 190 wheel on ground I have a great ride all the way up to 90 MPH. My point is that there doesn't seem to be any one spot that works for every bike. I would prefer to run lower tension, but it is what it is.

BLUEKNIGHT911
03-10-2020, 10:16 PM
I'm one of the rare birds who had to increase tension just a bit to get a smooth ride. My belt was 160 on the Kriket with the wheel on the ground and I got bad vibs from 55 to 65 MPH. I kept lowering the tension and test riding until I was down to 120 and still had vibes. Gave it a shot going the other direction and with the tension at 190 wheel on ground I have a great ride all the way up to 90 MPH. My point is that there doesn't seem to be any one spot that works for every bike. I would prefer to run lower tension, but it is what it is.

The general reports on Belt Tension here seems to be 150-160 using a KritKit checked on the ground …… I wonder if something is wrong with your belt ???? …… or Alignment …… Mike :ohyea:

MONK
03-10-2020, 10:34 PM
Monk, why don't you just skip dealership, come to my house, for kriket party? I have 36 mm socket, torque wrench. I have already had my rear wheel off for new tire.

forecast for Friday is rain, if we get too much, I don't have any work on new house as it would be a haul dirt in wheel barrow day. so Saturday might work out if you can come, might be a last minute decision.

hey Wahrsuul come on up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I try to do most of my Spyder and bike easy maintenance. I call this easy

rain date could be sunday afternoon

Saturday sounds good. I'll PM you.

Revalden
03-11-2020, 12:47 AM
Went on my 1st real ride at highway speeds today (about 70 miles of 65-75mph). Intermittantly, I'd get a vibration that felt like a really rough road (not like potholes rough but like...just rough). I could feel the vibrations in the floorboards. I've driven this stretch of road literally thousands of miles in the past couple of years and I don't recall (nor did I see) and bad sections of road. Definitely vibrations. More concerned since the Spyder only has about 650 miles on her.

If it had been a steady vibration, I'd have said it was a very unbalanced tire.

What say ye, fine citizens?

If you're riding a new Spyder, check to see if you got the old Kenda tires(get them off ASAP) or the new Kanines. Either way, have all three tires balanced by a real tire shop and get a Lazer Alignment.

Peter Aawen
03-11-2020, 03:32 AM
If you're riding a new Spyder, check to see if you got the old Kenda tires(get them off ASAP) or the new Kanines. Either way, have all three tires balanced by a real tire shop and get a Lazer Alignment.

I dunno Revalden.... I do agree that it's sounding very much like Monk has been one of the many who've been unlucky enough to score a set of dodgy OE Spec Kendas on their new Spyder, but if you're going to do what many others have found to be the only solution to their vibration problems and toss those OE Spec Kendas, is replacing them with a 'not yet proven' very similar tire from the same manufacturer really a viable option?!? :dontknow:

Surely, if you're deciding you should probably cut your losses and pay for new tires, then you hafta also ask yourself is it worth the risk of investing in the new Kenda Kanines on the off chance that they might be any better than the old OE Spec Kendas!! Personally, I wouldn't!! We already know that the Kanines have the same 'Special MotorCycle Use Only' warning on their sidewalls; and we know that their published construction details & data is very much the same as the OE Spec Kendas; and while some of the new Kanine 'unpaid Beta Testers' out there might be reporting smoother running in their early reports, there's really very little info on the boards to tell us how well these tires behave once they've done a few thousand miles..... :lecturef_smilie:

So, I guess it comes down to how lucky do you feel? Do you really want to fork out the premium $$ on a new set of Kanines that come out of the same factory as the old OE spec versions and HOPE they'll be any better than the notoriously unreliable OE Spec Kendas that so many get rid of; or would it be a smarter move to spend the $$ (and probably less $$ at that!) on a 'normal' auto tire, in the form of a known good quality tire from a reputable manufacturer.... :dontknow: I know what I'd be doing, and it certainly isn't spending any money on Kenda Kanines in the hope they're going to be any better.... at least not at this stage, not before there's any real long term evidence to suggest they aren't just another tire of notoriously unreliable construction quality where it seems almost as likely that you'll win the Lottery as it is that you might be lucky enough to get a good set?!? You don't play Russian Roulette with loaded firearms do you? If not, why would you play Russian Roulette with your tires before it becomes much clearer on how well these Kanines are going to turn out?! :shocked:

Navydad
03-11-2020, 01:48 PM
The general reports on Belt Tension here seems to be 150-160 using a KritKit checked on the ground …… I wonder if something is wrong with your belt ???? …… or Alignment …… Mike :ohyea:

Nope. Belt looks like new at 33,000 miles and alignment on both pulleys couldn't be prettier. 150 to 160 on the ground gets the vibes starting just past 55 and lasting to just shy of 65. Reducing tension moves the vibes very little. I currently have the tension at 185 range and it is smooth sailing past 80 MPH. The general consensus is why I kept lowering my tension to find the sweet spot that others have found. It ain't there :gaah: Raising the tension a bit found it :yes:

BLUEKNIGHT911
03-11-2020, 03:54 PM
Nope. Belt looks like new at 33,000 miles and alignment on both pulleys couldn't be prettier. 150 to 160 on the ground gets the vibes starting just past 55 and lasting to just shy of 65. Reducing tension moves the vibes very little. I currently have the tension at 185 range and it is smooth sailing past 80 MPH. The general consensus is why I kept lowering my tension to find the sweet spot that others have found. It ain't there :gaah: Raising the tension a bit found it :yes:

I can't think of why yours isn't like others here , including me ….. I think the 185 is still a bit below OEM spec...… good luck …. Mike :ohyea:

MONK
03-11-2020, 07:46 PM
If you're riding a new Spyder, check to see if you got the old Kenda tires(get them off ASAP) or the new Kanines. Either way, have all three tires balanced by a real tire shop and get a Lazer Alignment.


I dunno Revalden.... I do agree that it's sounding very much like Monk has been one of the many who've been unlucky enough to score a set of dodgy OE Spec Kendas on their new Spyder, but if you're going to do what many others have found to be the only solution to their vibration problems and toss those OE Spec Kendas, is replacing them with a 'not yet proven' very similar tire from the same manufacturer really a viable option?!? :dontknow:

Surely, if you're deciding you should probably cut your losses and pay for new tires, then you hafta also ask yourself is it worth the risk of investing in the new Kenda Kanines on the off chance that they might be any better than the old OE Spec Kendas!! Personally, I wouldn't!! We already know that the Kanines have the same 'Special MotorCycle Use Only' warning on their sidewalls; and we know that their published construction details & data is very much the same as the OE Spec Kendas; and while some of the new Kanine 'unpaid Beta Testers' out there might be reporting smoother running in their early reports, there's really very little info on the boards to tell us how well these tires behave once they've done a few thousand miles..... :lecturef_smilie:

So, I guess it comes down to how lucky do you feel? Do you really want to fork out the premium $$ on a new set of Kanines that come out of the same factory as the old OE spec versions and HOPE they'll be any better than the notoriously unreliable OE Spec Kendas that so many get rid of; or would it be a smarter move to spend the $$ (and probably less $$ at that!) on a 'normal' auto tire, in the form of a known good quality tire from a reputable manufacturer.... :dontknow: I know what I'd be doing, and it certainly isn't spending any money on Kenda Kanines in the hope they're going to be any better.... at least not at this stage, not before there's any real long term evidence to suggest they aren't just another tire of notoriously unreliable construction quality where it seems almost as likely that you'll win the Lottery as it is that you might be lucky enough to get a good set?!? You don't play Russian Roulette with loaded firearms do you? If not, why would you play Russian Roulette with your tires before it becomes much clearer on how well these Kanines are going to turn out?! :shocked:

Three things. First, how would I know if I have the old crappy tires or the new crappy tires? This has the original tires from 2018 (probably manufactured in 2017 although I haven't looked @ the date code) so I'm guessing it probably has the old ones?

Second, whenever I replace the tires (soon or not), I'll probably put Vederestestenien 5Qs on (I have no idea how to spell that but I saved the thread to my computer favorites).

Finally, I'm sure I could use a lazer alignment but I'm way beyond tapped out right now. I'm to the point where I'm doubting the brilliance of buying the Spyder.

Eckhard
03-11-2020, 09:30 PM
What model and year of Spyder we talking about?

MONK
03-11-2020, 09:31 PM
2018 rtl

Peter Aawen
03-11-2020, 10:42 PM
Monk, if your tires don't say 'Kanine' on their sidewalls, then they are the OE Spec Kendas - the old crappy tires. Those are still the tires that are being fitted during manufacture by BRP onto Spyders & Rykers as their Original Equipment tires, and to some degree they are still the 'Dealer directed/BRP Preferred' option as r erplacements, altho Kenda have released the Kanine's as an alternative 'after-market' option & some Dealers are prepared to fit them for you (just don't post their name on the public pages, BRP have reportedly come down hard on some Dealers who've been identified via social media as straying from the Company line!! :shocked: )

That said, the Kanine's share much of their construction and design detail with the OE spec Kendas fitted to our Spyders/Rykers, and they come out of the same manufacturing plant too, so as I said in that earlier post, until we've seen how they perform for a few thousand miles (or preferably , for some TENS of thousands of miles - at least 2 x 10, & preferably 3 or more! ;) ) then no-one really knows if they are any better, the same, or if they might be worse.... (if that's even possible!?! :shocked: ) While we yet remain to see about the Kanines, fitting just about any quality car tire should be a step up from the Kendas, just so long as you remember they won't need to run at quite the same pressure as is necessary for them to carry a larger & heavier auto; but the Vredsteins certainly seem to fit the bill for many and have so far proven to be up amongst if not actually the best choice available for many Spyder Ryders right now - it's just a shame that we can't get them here in Australia?! :thumbup:

As for the wheel alignment, it does seem that BRP & their Dealers have become a lot better at getting the alignment right or close to right before releasing the Spyders to their new owners - certainly here in Aust we aren't seeing the massive miss-alignments on 9 out of every 10 Spyders that we used to, so there's a good chance your alignment isn't awful, altho it still might not be ideal. From what we've seen here on the Forum, it appears that most 'non-dealer alignments' cost in the vicinity of $120-$150, and considering how easily & quickly an incorrect alignment can kill a set of tires, plus the steering & safety issues a bad alignment can cause, it's not really an awful price to pay, is it?! That said, 'vibrations' at speed are usually (but not necessarily exclusively) more to do with tire balance problems, defective or failing tire construction/integrity (arguably fairly common amongst OE spec Kendas?! :dontknow: ) or other defective/damaged suspension &/or steering components.... so maybe an alignment isn't the first thing you should be looking at doing anyway? :lecturef_smilie:

Good Luck & please persist, I'm sure you'll love it once you get thru the 'making it yours' and the 'un-paid beta-testing' phase?! :rolleyes: Once the bugs are ironed out, they really can give you Miles of Smiles! :thumbup:

And just a warning about the potential for spending more $$... after an ECU Upgrade, that Miles of Smiles thing becomes 'a permanently affixed Grin a Mile Wide!' :ohyea: :yes: :clap: :2thumbs:

Navydad
03-12-2020, 11:43 AM
I can't think of why yours isn't like others here , including me ….. I think the 185 is still a bit below OEM spec...… good luck …. Mike :ohyea:

Changed oil and took a short ride yesterday to verify oil level. Bike was smooth as silk. Broke out the Kriket for giggles and check the tension again. It was at 180 which is still below spec. I'm going to leave it alone. I have no clue why mine is bucking the trend. I had a 2004 BMW 1150RT with 120,000 miles on the original clutch and rear drive. Folks found that hard to believe as well. Always the odd guy out, go figure :dontknow:

BLUEKNIGHT911
03-12-2020, 11:57 AM
Monk, if your tires don't say 'Kanine' on their sidewalls, then they are the OE Spec Kendas - the old crappy tires. Those are still the tires that are being fitted during manufacture by BRP onto Spyders & Rykers as their Original Equipment tires, and to some degree they are still the 'Dealer directed/BRP Preferred' option as r erplacements, altho Kenda have released the Kanine's as an alternative 'after-market' option & some Dealers are prepared to fit them for you (just don't post their name on the public pages, BRP have reportedly come down hard on some Dealers who've been identified via social media as straying from the Company line!! :shocked: )

That said, the Kanine's share much of their construction and design detail with the OE spec Kendas fitted to our Spyders/Rykers, and they come out of the same manufacturing plant too, so as I said in that earlier post, until we've seen how they perform for a few thousand miles (or preferably , for some TENS of thousands of miles - at least 2 x 10, & preferably 3 or more! ;) ) then no-one really knows if they are any better, the same, or if they might be worse.... (if that's even possible!?! :shocked: ) While we yet remain to see about the Kanines, fitting just about any quality car tire should be a step up from the Kendas, just so long as you remember they won't need to run at quite the same pressure as is necessary for them to carry a larger & heavier auto; but the Vredsteins certainly seem to fit the bill for many and have so far proven to be up amongst if not actually the best choice available for many Spyder Ryders right now - it's just a shame that we can't get them here in Australia?! :thumbup:

As for the wheel alignment, it does seem that BRP & their Dealers have become a lot better at getting the alignment right or close to right before releasing the Spyders to their new owners - certainly here in Aust we aren't seeing the massive miss-alignments on 9 out of every 10 Spyders that we used to, so there's a good chance your alignment isn't awful, altho it still might not be ideal. From what we've seen here on the Forum, it appears that most 'non-dealer alignments' cost in the vicinity of $120-$150, and considering how easily & quickly an incorrect alignment can kill a set of tires, plus the steering & safety issues a bad alignment can cause, it's not really an awful price to pay, is it?! That said, 'vibrations' at speed are usually (but not necessarily exclusively) more to do with tire balance problems, defective or failing tire construction/integrity (arguably fairly common amongst OE spec Kendas?! :dontknow: ) or other defective/damaged suspension &/or steering components.... so maybe an alignment isn't the first thing you should be looking at doing anyway? :lecturef_smilie:

Good Luck & please persist, I'm sure you'll love it once you get thru the 'making it yours' and the 'un-paid beta-testing' phase?! :rolleyes: Once the bugs are ironed out, they really can give you Miles of Smiles! :thumbup:

And just a warning about the potential for spending more $$... after an ECU Upgrade, that Miles of Smiles thing becomes 'a permanently affixed Grin a Mile Wide!' :ohyea: :yes: :clap: :2thumbs:

And …...most important … the Kanines still have " for special motorcycle use only " …. in raised letters on the sidewall ….. not a good sign :banghead::gaah:...... Mike :ohyea:

ZuluEcho
03-12-2020, 02:00 PM
No one has mentioned belt harmonics... I have experienced vibrations at some speeds, always within the same range (75-80), above or below that the vibration disappears. The belt is oscillating as it moves. When you reach a certain speed, the wave frequency of that oscillation gets out of wack and produces mechanical vibration. Once the speed is changed , and hence the frequency of the oscillations, the vibration stops. Belt tensioners can help, but rarely (as I understand) get rid of the whole problem. BRP should have gone with a drive shaft, but there you have it...

MONK
03-12-2020, 06:41 PM
I can dig that but...the vibrations would come and go while at the same speed. (I had the cruise on.)

Peter Aawen
03-12-2020, 07:18 PM
I can dig that but...the vibrations would come and go while at the same speed. (I had the cruise on.)

Sounding more'n more like tires..... :shocked:

Could be tires reacting to barely perceptible changes in the road surface; could even be as simple as a 'slightly odd' tread wear pattern giving you a different feel &/or creating vibrations as your steering & suspension angles change slightly as you ryde along; or it could be the tread/compound layers separating &/or the internals of the tire construction (plies or cords et al) moving/being moved in ways they really shouldn't; ..... but it's all sounding more'n more like it's the tires! :shocked:

h0gr1der
03-12-2020, 08:29 PM
I can dig that but...the vibrations would come and go while at the same speed. (I had the cruise on.)

Mine had that exact problem. I would notice the vibration occurring at the very start of a hill, but if I added throttle or slowed slightly it would go away. It has to do with the belt length and load/speed the belt is running at. When my belt was at maximum spec for tension it was a nasty buzz. I kept lowing the tensions, and logging the results. Like NavyDad, I hit a sweet spot around 170-180 Krikit Lbs. Changed my rear Kenda for a Vredestein and never found the sweet spot again. Finally just went to lowest spec tension and that was almost as good so I just stayed there.

canamjhb
03-12-2020, 10:45 PM
For the 3 years I have been on this forum I don't think I have ever disagreed with anything Peter has contributed...... until now. I think you are experiencing belt harmonics. Here is what I experienced with my (former) 2014 RTL. It was consistently dangerous to ride under any conditions above 65MPH. I Added BajaRon bar, added Elka shocks, had it laser aligned and all front end checked. It was still bad at 65+. I then changed out the OEM tires that still looked very good and the bike began to behave like I thought it should. But I still experienced a load related vibration like you have. Going up a hill and maintaining a constnt speed, I would feel a vibration. If I rolled on the throttle, it would go away. I knew this was not a speed related problem like I had with the tires. I then lowered the belt tension and added a damper. Vibrations disappeared. I think different bikes will react differently and if I had to do it again, I would probably just go with the lower belt tension and forgo the damper. I wound up having my belt tension at 160 on the Krikit gage. I could feel a very slight vibration at about 40MPH but nothing more. Good luck..... Jim

PMK
03-13-2020, 01:22 AM
Went on my 1st real ride at highway speeds today (about 70 miles of 65-75mph). Intermittantly, I'd get a vibration that felt like a really rough road (not like potholes rough but like...just rough). I could feel the vibrations in the floorboards. I've driven this stretch of road literally thousands of miles in the past couple of years and I don't recall (nor did I see) and bad sections of road. Definitely vibrations. More concerned since the Spyder only has about 650 miles on her.

If it had been a steady vibration, I'd have said it was a very unbalanced tire.

What say ye, fine citizens?

Kind of watched, read and noted the replies being somewhat varied, each with their own merit.

Without doing some actual hands on work to your Spyder, I admit my post is simply an experienced guess.

Multiple items have the possibility to create vibrations. The road, tires, the belt, the engine and even the airflow over the machine.

You mention being kind of at your limit currently, so that plays into troubleshooting. Add to that, it appears you openly admitted to having minimal tools for some of the tasks. Again, another factor that plays into it.

That said, and I do not know specifically what the issue is.

My thought though it a very systematic way to troubleshoot with the least amount of effort.

If you are able to visit the local person offering to help, that is huge, especially if he is open to help.

Knowing the difficulty level of the tasks stated to accomplish, and no assurance as to what will make a noticed change to actually place blame on something, this would be my approach if possible.

I assume the person offering help has a jack and torque wrench. If so, ask nicely if he will allow you to swap the left front wheel / tire assembly from your Spyder to his and his wheel assembly onto yours. Each give a test ride. Did the vibration remain on your Spyder, or did it follow onto his Spyder? Make notes of any changes.

Next swap the other wheel assemblies, and test again.

Even if the problem followed with the first wheel assembly swap, accomplish the second and note the changes.

At this point, as you swap wheel assemblies back to where they were installed originally, give the tires a spin, and watch for any wobble in the tread pattern and also any lack of roundness or humps. Again make notes.

Swapping and testing wheel assemblies is easy and validates if the tires are the issue. If the tires are round and have no or minimal wobble to the tread, but the vibration seems tire related, consider having an automotive shop properly dynamically balance the tires.

Since rhe jack may already be out and ready to work, next raise the Spyders rear wheel off the ground. Give a few check with the Cricket tool in one belt position. Then spin the rear tire and check belt tension in another spot. Do this few times and kind of see how things average out.

With the wheel raised, also grab the rear pulley and see if the bearing is worn, by inspecting for a wobble by grabbing at the 6 / 12 hand positions.

Check rear wheel bearings also, looking for a wobble when grabbing at the 6 / 12 hand positions.

If the belt tension exceeds 140lbf (pounds force) make adjustments, to lower the tension. The TSB belt tension range is 120 lbf to 160 lbf. Most people that have run 140 or below towards 120 have obtained excellent results.

Lastly, by your friend some lunch, you both earned it, him more so if he was kind enough to adjust belt tension and let you roll his tires a few miles.

Woodaddict
03-13-2020, 02:26 AM
i assume the person offering help has a jack and torque wrench. If so, ask nicely if he will allow you to swap the left front wheel / tire assembly from your spyder to his and his wheel assembly onto yours. Each give a test ride. Did the vibration remain on your spyder, or did it follow onto his spyder? Make notes of any changes.

Next swap the other wheel assemblies, and test again.

Even if the problem followed with the first wheel assembly swap, accomplish the second and note the changes.

At this point, as you swap wheel assemblies back to where they were installed originally, give the tires a spin, and watch for any wobble in the tread pattern and also any lack of roundness or humps. Again make notes.

Swapping and testing wheel assemblies is easy and validates if the tires are the issue. If the tires are round and have no or minimal wobble to the tread, but the vibration seems tire related, consider having an automotive shop properly dynamically balance the tires....

my plan was to jack up wheels and spin the tire. But yes, we could even swap the wheels. But first we can ride each others spyders, i have car ties on(3), laser alignment, centranamic balancers, along with about 165 on kriket. And most of all currant black, which makes it glide thru the air!!

PMK
03-13-2020, 02:54 AM
MY PLAN WAS TO JACK UP WHEELS AND SPIN THE TIRE. BUT YES, WE COULD EVEN SWAP THE WHEELS. BUT FIRST WE CAN RIDE EACH OTHERS SPYDERS, I HAVE CAR TIES ON(3), LASER ALIGNMENT, CENTRANAMIC BALANCERS, ALONG WITH ABOUT 165 ON KRIKET. AND MOST OF ALL CURRANT BLACK, WHICH MAKES IT GLIDE THRU THE AIR!!

Sorry to impose suggestions to make you work harder.

PinkRosePetal
03-13-2020, 07:34 AM
I can dig that but...the vibrations would come and go while at the same speed. (I had the cruise on.)
That's exactly how the belt issue manifests itself, as the cruise control opens the throttle the vibration is felt then as it backs off the throttle the vibration disappears. The cruise is constantly adjusting the throttle so the vibes come and go. If you climb an incline the cruise opens the throttle more so you feel the vibes more, then it backs off and the vibes disappear.

The fact it's happening to your bike in the 60ish mph range indicates that your drive belt is just on the slacker side of its adjustment range.
Personally, I think you're being given a lot of worry beads in this thread. I'd adjust the belt a little slacker and take it for a ride, you may find you've almost no vibration or it is less but at slightly lower speed. If you run the belt pretty slack but the vibration remains where it is at present, then you might look elsewhere for the issue.

A golden rule when fault finding...only ever test one change at a time otherwise you won't know what fixed the issue. Of course, you knew that... :)

MONK
03-13-2020, 07:59 PM
Thanks, guys. I was going to make a trip down to Woodaddicts house tomorrow but my folks (in their mid 70s) aren't feeling well and have some other health issues. Until I know they don't have this beer virus, I decided to stick closer to home (they live about 45 minutes north of me, Woodaddict is about 1.5 hours south of me). If they get better (meaning they just have bad colds), I'll reschedule w/Woodaddict.

Frostbyte
03-15-2020, 03:55 PM
I have read all the posts in this thread so far and would like to add my 2 cents worth.
As an ex National Bureau of Standards Lab Rat that specialized in Physical Dimensional measurement, calibration and repair and who is currently dealing with this issue on my new 2019 RT with just over 2k miles on it I, from experience, know it is belt tension as a function of length between pulley contact points.

What's occurring is Resonant Frequency Amplification. There is tons of math and physics involved, so I will try to explain it simply. I will be the first to admit I hated doing resonance work in the lab, 'cause it was too much trial and error because of all the variables...but it was part of my job. To give you an idea of what they were like, we used to call them "Guess and Go's".

Simply put, Resonant Frequency (RF) on our drive belt is primarily a function of length, temperature and tension. Length remains a constant determined by axle adjustment (Distance between pulleys). Tension is constantly variable through load, speed and belt temperature. As we ride, the belt is always "Twanging" like a guitar string, whether we can see it or not, and the frequency of the "note" is always changing. However, once the note hits the resonant frequency of the bike's frame, that note amplifies and is felt throughout the entire machine as a vibration as the bike "rings" in harmony with the belt, which in turn, causes the belt to ring even louder. It turns into a self amplifying circle. Any change to one of the variables causes the note to rise above or drop below resonance causing the vibration to diminish or stop entirely. That's why it will come and go even on cruise on level ground.
A shifting breeze will even affect it because of the slight change in loading.

Anyway, all we can do is find the happy medium to mitigate the effects of it as it will always be lurking there somewhere, at some speed, at some load and temperature.
Using a tensioner is one solution, as it effectively shifts the frequency into a higher octave by "halving" the belt length between contact points, much like placing your finger on a guitar fret halfway down the neck. Changing belt tension is another means of shifting the resonance, like tuning that same string.

I'm looking to shift mine first through belt tension so the RF occurs at above 80 since I rarely ride faster than that. Failing that, I will look to adding a tensioner and work with a combination of the two to find the "Sweet Spot" for me.
Currently, my vibration at 78~80 is so bad it almost feels like I'm riding a vibrator, and it's driving me nuts since I do 50 miles daily freeway running at those speeds.

Frostbyte
03-15-2020, 04:11 PM
As an add on to the above post, if I DO go with a tensioner, I will be sure to NOT have the tension pulley dead center of the belt length. That would double my trouble through Harmonics. Off-center the tension pulley by an odd measurement so the Resonant Frequencies are different, and to a point self-cancelling through phase shifting...I know, here I go with "Lab Speak" again...Please forgive me folks, just trying to help.

PinkRosePetal
03-15-2020, 04:30 PM
Yeh, but the real question is: Why do some bikes pluck the string and others don't?

And, don't place your tensioner at the 7th fret or you'll get the second harmonic.

And, with resonance at 80mph your belt will be too tight and you'll likely get a bearing whine at low speeds in the lower gears. ;)

Frostbyte
03-15-2020, 06:56 PM
Yeh, but the real question is: Why do some bikes pluck the string and others don't?

And, don't place your tensioner at the 7th fret or you'll get the second harmonic.

And, with resonance at 80mph your belt will be too tight and you'll likely get a bearing whine at low speeds in the lower gears. ;)

I like your attitude:firstplace:

I'm very well aware of axial loading and it's warning whine. That's why if I can't remedy it with just mild belt tension adjustments, I will add a tensioner, shifting it forwards and back on the swingarm, combining it with tension changes until I find my sweet spot. I'm not afraid to work at it till I get it right.

But like I wrote in the first post, there are too many variables to mention, everything from metal wall thickness, weld profiles and compounding impurities to rider weight which can cause resonance amplification or dampening. No 2 bikes are EXACTLY alike, even if they rolled off the line nose to tail, so they will all respond differently. And after riding, building and wrenching on bikes as a side job/hobby/love for over 50 years, I have run into a lot of weird problems I had to figure out.

To be honest, the only reason I looked at the Spyder in the first place was because I can't have a knee replacement due to a genetic condition and my Ortho told me I could either keep my Harley, or my leg, because when my knee finally goes, I lose the leg from the knee down. (Backing up a Thousand Pounds of glide at least twice daily was destroying what's left of it)

On the up side, in all the bikes I've owned in the last 50+ years, it is the most fun to ride and I wouldn't trade it for anything!:thumbup::ani29: